Re: 2012 QB Class
 

[quote=WaldSkins;861791]The only two QBs that I feel are sure things are Luck and Barkley.[/quote]

I feel that Luck is the only sure thing in terms of a guy that can be put in virtually any system, with any supporting cast, and any coach and succeed in terms of at least pulling his weight.

Re: 2012 QB Class
 

[quote=SkinItup;862481]RG3 all the way. Makes plays in the clutch, look at the last two weeks against Kansas and Oklahoma. Generally makes good decisions under pressure. He can throw on the run and always keeps his eyes down field. Can make plays with his feet alone. His mobility would help the oline situation much like Vick does in Philly and is a much better pocket passer than Vick was coming out of college. Accurate passer with good mechanics though the ball does seem to wobble a bit too frequently, but that is okay when it is consistently on the numbers/over the shoulder. My biggest concerns for him are he doesn't seem to always read the defense over the middle well. also he doesn't work from under the center but since all his other mechanics are good I'[m sure he can figure that one out. Look at his game against Oklahoma here

[url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=txEtv2cJS90]Robert Griffin III vs Oklahoma 2011 - YouTube[/url]

I am not sold on Barkley one bit. His play against Oregon was spotty. A few great throws yes but two dropped snaps and one where he tried to throw after picking it up and pretty much hit an Oregon player in the numbers, luckily it was dropped. Looked alot like a bad Romo and Grossman game. He can see all his throws here

[url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7g3r3wYz_6I]Matt Barkley vs Oregon 2011 - YouTube[/url]

judge for yourself.[/quote]

Both are really good. RG3 last throw and the throw at the 5 min mark are solid. Barkley had to throw against tighter coverage all night, which is more difficult. Good god, Oklahoma's secondary is flat out turrrrrble. How the f*ck did they make it through the year with such poor coverage, I mean they are horrible.

Re: 2012 QB Class
 

So wait, if Griffin is going to return to school in 2012, he does need to get granted that medical redshirt, right? He has played in four seasons. I'm aware of his injury that cost him most of his 2009 season, but you can't just pass the draft and plan on playing in 2012. He actually needs the NCAA's approval to stay at Baylor longer.

I realize that medical redshirts are often handed out like candy, but it seems like merely having the application process could be a major deterrent to him returning next season. The guy is a 21 year old senior which is really rare for a quarterback. Andrew Luck will be 23 by Week 2 of next season. And that's not old at all for a rookie QB.

Luck, Griffin, and Barkley could go 1, 2, 3 in this draft. And not one of them would be overdrafted.

Just to be safe, I hope the Redskins get the no. 2 pick. If one of them stays in school, that no. 3 pick could be worthless (relatively speaking).

Re: 2012 QB Class
 

Nevermind, Griffin has already been granted that Redshirt.

Re: 2012 QB Class
 

[quote=Chico23231;862496]Both are really good. RG3 last throw and the throw at the 5 min mark are solid. Barkley had to throw against tighter coverage all night, which is more difficult. Good god, Oklahoma's secondary is flat out turrrrrble. How the f*ck did they make it through the year with such poor coverage, I mean they are horrible.[/quote]


They call themselves "Sharks" Yeah I guess for Biting on playfakes all night

Re: 2012 QB Class
 

RGIII all the way for me. We're not going to get Luck and while Barkley looks like he's going to be a very good pro QB, I'd love for us to have a game changing athlete for once. Griffin has a combination of skills that aren't quite a replica of anyone specific but he seems to do a lot of things very well. Yes, there would be a bit of a process getting comfortable under center but he's already graduated, an honors student and a student of the game. This is a pick that we have to make.

Re: 2012 QB Class
 

[quote=Paintrain;862578]RGIII all the way for me. We're not going to get Luck and while Barkley looks like he's going to be a very good pro QB, I'd love for us to have a game changing athlete for once. Griffin has a combination of skills that aren't quite a replica of anyone specific but he seems to do a lot of things very well. Yes, there would be a bit of a process getting comfortable under center but he's already graduated, an honors student and a student of the game. This is a pick that we have to make.[/quote]


No doubt RG3 as well. .I saw him in person Saturday and was amazed

Re: 2012 QB Class
 

I knew Barkley was a lifelong USC fan and ESPN just confirmed it with a video of an 8 year old Barkley talking about being a QB for SC and "throwing some nice passes." I still say he stay's but I hope that first I'm wrong and second we're in position to get him.

Re: 2012 QB Class
 

This guy has been nothing short of spectacular this year. His combination of athleticism, arm strength, and accuracy makes him a top prospect in my eyes. Luck is getting all the hype and praise while guys like RG3, Barkley, and Foles are getting overlooked. This is how I think RG3 messures up.

5= elite
4= above average
3= average
2= below average
1= poor

Arm Strength: I think RG3 has a well above average arm strength, but not elite arm strength. He has more than enough arm strength to make every single NFL throw.

Grade 4

Accuracy: One of the things that makes RG3 so intriguing is his unbelievable accuracy definitely on the deep ball. This guy has excellent ball placement in the pocket and on the run.

Grade 5

Mechanics: The perfect over-the-top throwing motion RG3 displays is great. He has a quick release to go along with his perfect throwing motion. My only knock on his mechanic is that he sometimes throw the ball off his back foot when doesn't have too. Also his footwork not so good at times. With a little work and good coach this part of his game can be elite.

Grade 3

Pocket Presences: RG3 has a pretty good grasp of sensing pressure. He takes some sacks. However, he usually gets rid of the before taking the sack.

Grade 4

Athleticism: RG3 semifinalist at the Olympic Trials in the 400 hurdles following high school. He has shown the ability to elude would be sacks and turn them into big gains. He's very dangerous in the open field. There are few players that has his speed and elusiveness at qb.

Grade 5

Intangiblies: RG3 is a real character guy. He's an excellent student. He's proven to be a true leader on the field and in the locker room. He's a great competitor.

Grade 5

Summary: Robert Griffin is the most exciting prospects that I have seen in many years. It's rare to find a qb with his athleticism that has great passing ability as well. At the next level I believe he will give many defense fits with his arm and his legs. I think he's the best fit for what we do offensively.

Overall= 5

Re: 2012 QB Class
 

[quote=Dirtbag59;862593]I knew Barkley was a lifelong USC fan and ESPN just confirmed it with a video of an 8 year old Barkley talking about being a QB for SC and "throwing some nice passes." I still say he stay's but I hope that first I'm wrong and second we're in position to get him.[/quote]

Couldn't agree more!!

Re: 2012 QB Class
 

There's something about RG III I still struggle with. Not quite sure what it is.

I want to see more of Tannehill and I want to like Foles more.

Re: 2012 QB Class
 

[quote=SmootSmack;862835]There's something about RG III I still struggle with. Not quite sure what it is.

I want to see more of Tannehill and I want to like Foles more.[/quote]

i dont understand the hype about foles. i dont think he would be a good fit here. tannehill could be but it would take some time. hes not ready to play for several years imo. barkley, luck, RG3 are the qbs we should be thinking about (not that i think we will get luck...). the other ones im not much of a fan of.

Re: 2012 QB Class
 

[quote=SmootSmack;862835]There's something about RG III I still struggle with. Not quite sure what it is.

I want to see more of Tannehill and I want to like Foles more.[/quote] It's the offense he runs.

Re: 2012 QB Class
 

Pretty lame that all QB prospect talk is being forced into a single thread.

No one wants to sit here and read through 375 posts at one time.

Re: 2012 QB Class
 

You want one for each prospect?

Re: 2012 QB Class
 

[quote=SmootSmack;862846]You want one for each prospect?[/quote]

It's certainly better than a 375-post thread that must be waded through.

Why not just make a thread titled "Football" with no other threads allowed?

These monster threads just seem silly an unnecessary. It certainly makes the board a lot less reader friendly.