Re: Would you take McNabb?
 

Enough with over the hill players. Out with old, in with the new.

Re: Would you take McNabb?
 

Have you been watching this team for the last decade?

Re: Would you take McNabb?
 

Hmm, do i want a qb that chokes under pressure and has a habit of throwing bounce passes to his wr's? Uh, no.

Re: Would you take McNabb?
 

[quote=SmootSmack;653712]The Eagles don't need to trade McNabb to shore up cap space. Whoever started that rumor is mistaken. The Eagles [I]might[/I] trade McNabb, though I think Kolb is more likely, to add some defensive help if they feel that's the last piece they need to get Reid and McNabb that elusive ring.

And no I wouldn't trade for him.[/quote]

Would you trade for Kolb? he's a veteran/backup WCO Quarterback. he'd come alot cheaper than a QB at 4, thats for sure.

Re: Would you take McNabb?
 

[quote=Longtimefan;653716]To answer your question would I take him, yes I'd take him but I would not trade for him. The Eagles would never trade him to us anyway as long as Andy Reid is their coach. I question McNabb's decision making anymore, some of his problem could be his supporting cast, [SIZE=4]and the fact he's been mssing more than 50% of his offense in the absence of Westbrook.[/quote][/SIZE]

I don't think Westbrook is 50% of their offense anymore and he is probably going to play more of a suport role over the next couple of years.

Re: Would you take McNabb?
 

no!!!

Re: Would you take McNabb?
 

[quote=firstdown;653734][/SIZE]

I don't think Westbrook is 50% of their offense anymore and he is probably going to play more of a suport role over the next couple of years.[/quote]

I'd be pretty surprised if Westbrook is an Eagle next year. He's due nearly $8M and can't stay healthy anymore, plus he's an OLD 31. The Iggles have showed no qualms with cutting aging vets who've been with the team for years- Runyan, Tra Thomas, and Dawkins come to mind.

I think McNabb however will be an Eagle for another year, maybe two. If he's not though, I don't want him. I'd rather not give up high draft picks for a guy who turns 34 this year.

Re: Would you take McNabb?
 

I just don't want the Eagles to ever win a ring. That's the one thing I know I can always say to an Eagles fan.

Re: Would you take McNabb?
 

No only because he's like 34!! He's done , I just want to start fresh

Re: Would you take McNabb?
 

Hell no.

Re: Would you take McNabb?
 

[quote=RobH4413;653707]I wouldn't. Eagles would only give him up for a high price... and that price (especially in a divisional trade) would certainly not be worth it. Makes no sense.[/quote]Good call. No way the Eagles trade him to us unless it's an incredibly bad deal.

Re: Would you take McNabb?
 

[quote=BleedBurgundy;653723]Hmm, do i want a qb that chokes under pressure and has a habit of throwing bounce passes to his wr's? Uh, no.[/quote]
so you don't want campbell either?

Re: Would you take McNabb?
 

[quote=tryfuhl;653815]so you don't want campbell either?[/quote]

Campbell doesn't choke under pressure, he chokes because of the defensive lineman that is on top of him 3 seconds after snapping the ball.

Re: Would you take McNabb?
 

[quote=Ruhskins;653818]Campbell doesn't choke under pressure, he chokes because of the defensive lineman that is on top of him 3 seconds after snapping the ball.[/quote]
Even with adequate protection he has an issue in long-field situations. Not completely his fault, just pointing it out.

Re: Would you take McNabb?
 

hell no?