Re: Are We Critiquing the Wrong Coaches?
 

I think it's a bit lame to keep blaming Gibbs. Don't get me wrong, he is definitely the one that is ultimately responsible and he is always the first to admit that.

But, the guys under him are very experienced and 3 of them have been head coaches in this league at some point. It's certainly fair to point some fingers at the guys below him. Gibbs has delegated a lot of responsibility to them and I don't think we can say that they have come through with their end of the deal.

Again, everything does ultimately fall back on the head guy. But that certainly doesn't absolve everyone else from sharing in the blame. Coaches and players alike.

Re: Are We Critiquing the Wrong Coaches?
 

Does anyone think that it might be time for Bugel to hang up the whistle? He's been in the NFL for over 30 years now and he's accomplished great things in that time, but what does he add to the team anymore? The same goes for Don Breaux, Jack Burns, & Rennie Simmons. All these are great guys and I'm sure they add something to the team, but do they see eye to eye with Al Saunders?
When Saunders was brought in, how many of 'his guys' actually came with him? I would think he would have wanted to bring in a staff more familiar with his system to help ease the learning process. It seems like the only people who came over with Saunders were Todd Collins and Al's son, Bob.

I might be reaching here but this is just something I was thinking about the other day.

Re: Are We Critiquing the Wrong Coaches?
 

[quote=ArtMonkDrillz;256982]Does anyone think that it might be time for Bugel to hang up the whistle? He's been in the NFL for over 30 years now and he's accomplished great things in that time, but what does he add to the team anymore? The same goes for Don Breaux, Jack Burns, & Rennie Simmons. All these are great guys and I'm sure they add something to the team, but do they see eye to eye with Al Saunders?
When Saunders was brought in, how many of 'his guys' actually came with him? I would think he would have wanted to bring in a staff more familiar with his system to help ease the learning process. It seems like the only people who came over with Saunders were Todd Collins and Al's son, Bob.

I might be reaching here but this is just something I was thinking about the other day.[/quote]

4 words - Cut Blocking & Zone Blocking
An article last week (can't remember it exactly but think it was a washpost article about the o-line) had a quote from Buges saying something like "I don't like cut blocking but it's almost necessary in today's game."
This shows that Buges changed his ways before the carolina game & had the o-linemen block differently. The old HOg days where the o-line could just dominate by sheer force are over. Every team has speed & size on D.
This could be the result of some interesting exchanges between Saunders & Buges, maybe the result of Saunders showing him film of teams that have big run #s. Notice the last 2 weeks our run game has been awesome. If we'd had it early in the year...

Re: Are We Critiquing the Wrong Coaches?
 

I really don't see Bugel as a problem. The line has played well most of this year, not great but well. A lot of the blitz pickup problems seem to come from the backs or ends and even the scheme at times.

Re: Are We Critiquing the Wrong Coaches?
 

[QUOTE=ArtMonkDrillz;256982]Does anyone think that it might be time for Bugel to hang up the whistle?[/QUOTE]

I think Buges has done an ok job preparing his linemen. They were clicking right along last season before Thomas went down, and they haven't really done too bad of a job this season...at least in run blocking. I think it just goes back to having more athletic linemen in offenses that tend to be "high powered." For example, you definitely want athletic, quick linemen in Indy and not big guys who are more tailored for smashmouth football. I think Buges has had them ready for a true Joe Gibbs type of offense, but he too is having to adjust his guys to the new system.

Re: Are We Critiquing the Wrong Coaches?
 

[quote=skinsguy;256989]I think Buges has done an ok job preparing his linemen. They were clicking right along last season before Thomas went down, and they haven't really done too bad of a job this season...at least in run blocking. I think it just goes back to having more athletic linemen in offenses that tend to be "high powered." For example, you definitely want athletic, quick linemen in Indy and not big guys who are more tailored for smashmouth football. I think Buges has had them ready for a true Joe Gibbs type of offense, but he too is having to adjust his guys to the new system.[/quote]

Good point, bugel is definitely a gibbs guy and not a saunders guy, but maybe in the end it will give Buges some valuable experience.

Re: Are We Critiquing the Wrong Coaches?
 

[QUOTE=freddyg12;256984]4 words - Cut Blocking & Zone Blocking
An article last week (can't remember it exactly but think it was a washpost article about the o-line) had a quote from Buges saying something like "I don't like cut blocking but it's almost necessary in today's game."
This shows that Buges changed his ways before the carolina game & had the o-linemen block differently. The old HOg days where the o-line could just dominate by sheer force are over. Every team has speed & size on D.
This could be the result of some interesting exchanges between Saunders & Buges, maybe the result of Saunders showing him film of teams that have big run #s. Notice the last 2 weeks our run game has been awesome. If we'd had it early in the year...[/QUOTE]
I must have missed that article, but it's good to hear that he's not afraid to adjust his style to fit Saunders'.

Re: Are We Critiquing the Wrong Coaches?
 

[QUOTE=Mattyk72;256985]I really don't see Bugel as a problem. The line has played well most of this year, not great but well. A lot of the blitz pickup problems seem to come from the backs or ends and even the scheme at times.[/QUOTE]
That's probably has a lot to do with Portis being hurt/out all of the season.

Re: Are We Critiquing the Wrong Coaches?
 

It was a really good article, I'll try to find it and post a link.

Re: Are We Critiquing the Wrong Coaches?
 

Here it is

[url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/12/01/AR2006120101479.html]For Line, 'Crease' Is The Word - washingtonpost.com[/url]

Re: Are We Critiquing the Wrong Coaches?
 

[quote=Mattyk72;256999]Here it is

[URL="http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/12/01/AR2006120101479.html"]For Line, 'Crease' Is The Word - washingtonpost.com[/URL][/quote]

thanks for posting it Matty. It really does sound like Buges gave in on this one after being stubborn for so long. That's my read of it anyway.
I don't agree entirely w/your earlier post, the O-line has had games where we couldn't establish anything; dallas, nyg. we couldn't even run much on the titans.
Now on the other hand, when they've played well its been against good lines & its one part of the team that needs to stay as is. Re-sign Dock & get some depth in the draft & cheap fa's.

Re: Are We Critiquing the Wrong Coaches?
 

[quote=freddyg12;257052]thanks for posting it Matty. It really does sound like Buges gave in on this one after being stubborn for so long. That's my read of it anyway.
I don't agree entirely w/your earlier post, the O-line has had games where we couldn't establish anything; dallas, nyg. we couldn't even run much on the titans.
Now on the other hand, when they've played well its been against good lines & its one part of the team that needs to stay as is. Re-sign Dock & get some depth in the draft & cheap fa's.[/quote]

If anything the OL has been very inconsistent. We've seen them beat up on some very good defensive lines like Jacksonville, and like you said there were games were they couldn't get anything going.

Re: Are We Critiquing the Wrong Coaches?
 

[quote=Mattyk72;256806]Gibbs through the years has always been very stoic on the sidelines.

I guess Tom Coughlin's sideline gestures are really doing them a lot of good huh?

How about perhaps the most stone faced of coaches in the league, Bill Belichick? What's his deal? Somehow they win despite his lack of emotion.

I seriously don't know where people come up with this stuff sometimes. :rolleyes:[/quote]


And you are suggesting the coaches who show emotion are big losers.

I am pretty sure Coughlin won the NFC East last year and how about that loser Bill Cowher?

Oh no.... Wait .... Cowher won the Super Bowl.

Some how they win getting excitied about thier teams.

Re: Are We Critiquing the Wrong Coaches?
 

Ummmm, nooooo. Perhaps he is suggesting that different successful coaches have different coaching styles. History is replete with coaches who have been successful with both a less demonstrative manner (Landry?) and those who are more demonstrative (cowher).

Your original complaint was that Gibbs is too stoic. I would suggest to you, that his demeanor on the sidelines is similar (maybe even exactly the same) as it was during his superbowl seasons.

If your going to argue a point, it would really help if you remembered what it was.

Re: Are We Critiquing the Wrong Coaches?
 

I don't think there's a direct correlation between showing emotion and winning. It's all circumstantial really I think.