Re: Tony McGee On Redskins at 4-9
 

Brunell's passes for first downs in last four games:
8 Tennessee
12 Indy
10 Dallas
6 Philly

Campbell's passes for 1st downs:
12 Tampa
3!!!!! yikes Carolina
13 Atlanta
10 Philadelphia

Very Comparable

Re: Tony McGee On Redskins at 4-9
 

[quote=GTripp0012;259914]I don't have the exact numbers, but I read somewhere (I'll attempt to find a link, it was either on ESPN.com or Football Outsiders) that the Skins offense has decreased in every passing category except TDs, including 3rd down conversion pct.[/quote]

3rd down conversions and three and outs are not the same thing

Re: Tony McGee On Redskins at 4-9
 

Unfortunately, our defense has also been very successful at avoiding 3 and outs.

[quote=GTripp0012;259911]Our 3 and outs are pretty much the same under Campbell as they were under Brunell.

Our offense has done a good job this year avoiding 3 and outs.[/quote]

Re: Tony McGee On Redskins at 4-9
 

I think you mean 36.5% Brunell vs. 36.2% Campbell. (They had 52 third-down situations, not 42 in Brunell's last 4 games.)

[quote=GTripp0012;260010]45% for Brunell, 36% for Campbell.

I would be interested to see if Brunell's last four games are consistent with his first five games. Ideally, you want the sample size to be bigger than 4 games, but with JC thats all you have.[/quote]

Re: Tony McGee On Redskins at 4-9
 

[quote=mike340;260385]I think you mean 36.5% Brunell vs. 36.2% Campbell. (They had 52 third-down situations, not 42 in Brunell's last 4 games.)[/quote]

Guys honestly there is no question that Brunnel would win more games then campbell right now, the price of having a rookie. Dont judge Campbell now though judge him next year when you are wishing we kept Brunnel :)

Re: Tony McGee On Redskins at 4-9
 

what makes you think we would have won those games with brunell, just give me something here.....QB rating does not equal victories

Re: Tony McGee On Redskins at 4-9
 

[quote=Redskin;260392]Guys honestly there is no question that Brunnel would win more games then campbell right now, the price of having a rookie. Dont judge Campbell now though judge him next year when you are wishing we kept Brunnel :)[/quote]

How do you figure there's no question?

I think if there wasn't any question, Joe Gibbs doesn't bench Brunell. Seems pretty simple to me.

Re: Tony McGee On Redskins at 4-9
 

I'm a Brunell guy (although it was totally time to put JC in), and nothing I have read makes me think there is any ABSOLUTE reasoning that MB could have won anything that JC has not. Who is to say that the D and the O-line responded better to JC than MB. That is the rumor around Redskin park. JC still makes rookie mistakes, and will continue to for a while. He definately adds a dimension that MB seemed to have lost.