Re: Taylor Effing Heinicke
 

He was OK today. He got away with 1.

Re: Taylor Effing Heinicke
 

[QUOTE=sdskinsfan2001;1302605]He was OK today. He got away with 1.[/QUOTE]I think that may be his football epitaph.

Sent from my SM-G973U using Tapatalk

Re: Taylor Effing Heinicke
 

He will get lucky at times. All those gunslingers do. Yes that should have been a pick 6 but he’s also had some throws that should have been caught for TDs too.

Re: Taylor Effing Heinicke
 

Hopefully he is here next year the team leaders love him after watching Jon Allen speak. No way I want someone like Matty Ice or Wilson here they are washed! That would be so wft Modus Operandi over pay for a guy on the backside of his career who has been trending down the past 2 seasons and doesnt bring much if anything more then you have on the roster now.

You want to send Rodgers yea no brainier and probably Carr although he has a reputation as soft among players. I dont see anybody else Mariota hard no!

Re: Taylor Effing Heinicke
 

[quote=skinsfaninok;1302612]He will get lucky at times. All those gunslingers do. Yes that should have been a pick 6 but he’s also had some throws that should have been caught for TDs too.[/quote]

I agree playing these "what if scenarios" are always pointless. Never understand why people play them. People do this on the positive also, take away that one rbs 50 yard run and he only got 60 yards not 110, I always think yea whats your point!

Re: Taylor Effing Heinicke
 

[QUOTE=ODUWFT;1302614]Hopefully he is here next year the team leaders love him after watching Jon Allen speak. No way I want someone like Matty Ice or Wilson here they are washed! That would be so wft Modus Operandi over pay for a guy on the backside of his career who has been trending down the past 2 seasons and doesnt bring much if anything more then you have on the roster now.

You want to send Rodgers yea no brainier and probably Carr although he has a reputation as soft among players. I dont see anybody else Mariota hard no![/QUOTE]


Dude I love TH. You can go back to last year when I spent weeks arguing that he isn’t as fragile as everyone thinks. I loooove TH. BUT if you think Russ is washed you’re crazy. He is coming off an injury. I would trade TH straight up for Russ in a nano second. Actually quicker than that.

Re: Taylor Effing Heinicke
 

[quote=ODUWFT;1302614]Hopefully he is here next year the team leaders love him after watching Jon Allen speak. No way I want someone like Matty Ice or Wilson here they are washed! That would be so wft Modus Operandi over pay for a guy on the backside of his career who has been trending down the past 2 seasons and doesnt bring much if anything more then you have on the roster now.

You want to send Rodgers yea no brainier and probably Carr although he has a reputation as soft among players. I dont see anybody else Mariota hard no![/quote]

I don't think RW is washed up but he's going to be a NYG.. It's been rumored since June.. Apparently he wants to live and play in NY.

I think we have no choice but to keep TH

Re: Taylor Effing Heinicke
 

It is a tough thing w/ TH because he is a limited QB as far as arm talent goes but he makes plays. Have to remember that the goal is to try and win a SB, not be a playoff contender. IDK if our offense will be explosive enough to be a SB contender w/ him as our QB. Having 15 play drives is great but also you have to be able to make big plays and score. Can't win every game at 17-15.

Next week will be interesting. Cowboys are going to move the ball and score. Can we match them?

Re: Taylor Effing Heinicke
 

[quote=skinsfaninok;1302623]I don't think RW is washed up but he's going to be a NYG.. It's been rumored since June.. Apparently he wants to live and play in NY.

I think we have no choice but to keep TH[/quote]

Wilson still has plenty of good years ahead of him.

Re: Taylor Effing Heinicke
 

[quote=punch it in;1302622]Dude I love TH. You can go back to last year when I spent weeks arguing that [B]he isn’t as fragile as everyone thinks[/B]. I loooove TH. BUT if you think Russ is washed you’re crazy. He is coming off an injury. I would trade TH straight up for Russ in a nano second. Actually quicker than that.[/quote]

I think the evidentiary record was not on your side with that argument.

Given the injury to Fitz, we're lucky that they brought him back this year. He is playing just well enough to complement how well this defense is playing of late, but yeah I would trade him for Russell Wilson - easily.

Re: Taylor Effing Heinicke
 

[QUOTE=Chief X_Phackter;1302633]I think the evidentiary record was not on your side with that argument.

Given the injury to Fitz, we're lucky that they brought him back this year. He is playing just well enough to complement how well this defense is playing of late, but yeah I would trade him for Russell Wilson - easily.[/QUOTE]


Last year after the playoff game everyones knock was TH is fragile. I said over n over again that there was not a big enough sample size to consider him fragile. I think the evidentiary record was not on the side of anyone because again, there wasn’t enough of a sample size, or evidence at all.

We agree on him and Russ whole heartedly.

Re: Taylor Effing Heinicke
 

It wasn't just the playoff game that gave cause for concern over his ability to stay healthy. I'm glad it hasn't been an issue. At the time though it was a fair enough concern.

Re: Taylor Effing Heinicke
 

Well, the only samples we had were injury after injury everywhere he went, including last year's playoff game. I can see why people, including myself, concluded that he was injury prone. I'm glad he has managed to stay healthy this year.

Re: Taylor Effing Heinicke
 

Heinicke spent all offseason working on his body to be durable and it obviously paid off.. Heinicke has taken some hits yesterday and yet he continued to play and seems to not be injured other than being sore. So it seems like Heinicke didn't focus on strengthening his body in the beginning of his NFL career. This is a learning process and Heinicke has shown that he understood what he needs to do to be a legit QB in NFL.

Re: Taylor Effing Heinicke
 

[QUOTE=MTK;1302637]It wasn't just the playoff game that gave cause for concern over his ability to stay healthy. I'm glad it hasn't been an issue. At the time though it was a fair enough concern.[/QUOTE]


No doubt. But he did stay relatively healthy in college. And there were what 2-3 unrelated injuries. I always maintained that coming in cold after bench warming was a reason for the injuries in the pros.

Anyway im wrong alot so just give me the W here and we will move on. [emoji6]