Re: Grade Rocky McIntosh
 

[quote=That Guy]math: 3 picks (given) - 1 pick (received) = 2 picks lost.
we gave up 2 picks and used 1.[/quote]

God dam really.. let me explain you gave 3 picks and used 1 that you received if you substract the 1 you recevied you don't use anything.


let me explains in terms you might understand ok...... If I have a Babe Ruth rookie card and you want it and I say you need to give me your Hank Aaron, Mickey Mantle and Pete Rose cards for me to give you my Babe Ruth 1. How many card you need to give me?...................... 3 yeahhhhhh and how many card I'm going to give you? 1 ok thats math.

Re: Grade Rocky McIntosh
 

[quote=Paintrain]Bottomline is that the Skins have all of their starters locked up for the next 3 years and 19 of 22 are under the age of 30. Yes the draft is important but it's not the end all be all.[/quote]

Agreed but its the base of the future. See all championship teams they make good draft moves and pics and they usually have a lot of pics each year and is rare thay give future draft pics to move up wich is also rare see NE how they picked C.Jakson, or Philly or Denver none gave next year draft picks to move up and if they do they're usually second day late pics they know that.

because it usually bites you in the ass see Buffalo they gave us a 1st round pick to move up and draft JP Losman 2 years ago we drafted JJ,Spears and Eventually D.Bledsoe because they fired him because they need to start JP because of the money invested. Now it seem JP is a bust they want to trade and have nothing to show for we have 3 starters that simple.

Re: Grade Rocky McIntosh
 

[quote=D'BOYZ]God dam really.. let me explain you gave 3 picks and used 1 that you received if you substract the 1 you recevied you don't use anything.


let me explains in terms you might understand ok...... If I have a Babe Ruth rookie card and you want it and I say you need to give me your Hank Aaron, Mickey Mantle and Pete Rose cards for me to give you my Babe Ruth 1. How many card you need to give me?...................... 3 yeahhhhhh and how many card I'm going to give you? 1 ok thats math.[/quote]

its not my fault you don't get simple 6th grade math, but i don't blame you, you are a cowboys fan.

we gave up 3 picks, we got 1, instead of 3 players, we end up with 1, meaning we gave up 2 players. seriously, what's your problem understanding that? its not that hard.

Re: Grade Rocky McIntosh
 

[quote=That Guy]its not my fault you don't get simple 6th grade math, but i don't blame you, you are a cowboys fan.

we gave up 3 picks, we got 1, instead of 3 players, we end up with 1, meaning we gave up 2 players. seriously, what's your problem understanding that? its not that hard.[/quote]

ok I agree with you on that side man you gave up the right 2 draft 2 players totally agreed, but it's also correct what I said I don't know why you question it in the first place because you gave 3 picks for 1.

Re: Grade Rocky McIntosh
 

3 starters for JP Losman? Spears is a definite starter that will contribute, no argument there. JJ can't stay on the field long enough to gain Parcells confidence. And Bledsoe? Bledsoe? Bledsoe stepped out of the shower this morning and got sacked again by Phillip Daniels. During his time with Dallas has he led the team to the promised land? No, he throws it to the other team late in the fourth so they can score the game winning TD.

Re: Grade Rocky McIntosh
 

I definately have faith in our staff that they made the right decision on him. Its just not what I would have done in that situation. We paid too much for him.

Re: Grade Rocky McIntosh
 

And Bledsoe? Bledsoe? Bledsoe stepped out of the shower this morning and got sacked again by Phillip Daniels.
THAT's HUMOR!!

But seriously Dboys, you cannot be holding out Denver, NE, Philly as the model teams of the new Millenium??????? Only one of the three is even in the same league (from as accomplishment standpoint)as the SKINS under JOE. Incidently that includes Parcells. That having been said, why would we be inclined to follow that example? Joe is not afraid to be the innovator. Don't be afraid to Lead!

Re: Grade Rocky McIntosh
 

[quote=That Guy]its not my fault you don't get simple 6th grade math, but i don't blame you, you are a cowboys fan.

we gave up 3 picks, we got 1, instead of 3 players, we end up with 1, meaning we gave up 2 players. seriously, what's your problem understanding that? its not that hard.[/quote]

DBoy's is arguing over semantics. We used 3 picks to draft Rocky. But we only gave up two more than the second rounder we would have used anyway.

The point that is forgotten here is that we moved up from the end of the second round to the start of the second round. That costs something. For us to do it and aquire our target we had to trade our second rounders and give up two additional picks.

Re: Grade Rocky McIntosh
 

[quote=D'BOYZ]let me explains in terms you might understand ok...... If I have a Babe Ruth rookie card and you want it and I say you need to give me your Hank Aaron, Mickey Mantle and Pete Rose cards for me to give you my Babe Ruth 1. How many card you need to give me?...................... 3 yeahhhhhh and how many card I'm going to give you? 1 ok thats math.[/quote]

But that isn't really what is happening. You are trading your Bade Ruth card for a Barry Bonds card and you (obviously now) have to throw in a couple of other cards that you don't really know thier worth.

If it were just a one for one trade wouldn't it sound funny to hear someone say we traded, but I had to give up one card...

I think the traded card is implied.

Re: Grade Rocky McIntosh
 

i don't know how you compare a 6th round pick to hank aaron, pete rose or mickey mantle...

Re: Grade Rocky McIntosh
 

This thread is giving me a serious headache

Re: Grade Rocky McIntosh
 

[quote=That Guy]i don't know how you compare a 6th round pick to hank aaron, pete rose or mickey mantle...[/quote]

Go easy on him, he's a Cowboys fan, so by definition he doesn't really know what he's talking about.......he only thinks he does. He's probably still just bitter over the fact that his team lost to the Skins twice last year and couldn't make the playoffs.



Off topic? Yep, but I still enjoyed it.

Re: Grade Rocky McIntosh
 

I don't think it has to be that complicated.

The redskins gave up 2 picks to move up: (1) next year's 2nd rounder and (2) a 6th rounder this year. The moving up part was the redskins swapping our 2nd rounder with the Jets' 2nd rounder (moving up from 53 to 35).

I don't how that concept can be that complicated. And I am trying to think of some metaphor to help explain it, but anything more that I add would just confuse things even more.

Re: Grade Rocky McIntosh
 

[quote=D'BOYZ]it's not about the points it about the players you can get with your pics
[/quote]

Which must be why every single team in the NFL (including the Cowboys) subscribes to using the exact same point value chart?

Re: Grade Rocky McIntosh
 

I don't think the baseball card analogy is fair because we already have an assessed value of those cards. McIntosh's value is speculative as is any other player drafted as part of this trade. At best the analogy is: I'll trade you my (w*a), (x*a) and (y*a) for your (z*a). W, X, Y & Z are the anticipated future values of (a) player. The Redskins, obvoiusly must think that Z is going to be a greater value for them than a combination of W, X &/or Y.