Re: Skins vs Carolina Pre Game
 

[quote=SirLK26;1158953]Good post, imo we need a big dominant NT, at least one new safety, and maybe another corner if Breelands not the guy. Some of our young guys will be better next year, Cravens, Fuller, Smith, Ioannidis, could all turn into nice pieces. And if Galette returns we have an athletic pass rusher to rotate in instead of the plodders we have now. We could actually be solid on defense next year

Edit: Oh and of course a new D coordinator is a must[/quote]

Better off drafting DTs than a NT. Better yet if we don't get into the playoffs Barry will be probably out and maybe a 4-3 guy installed as DC. Never really heard of any real dominant NTs in the NFL. Those guys usually are just hole pluggers. We need a CB regardless of Breeland, but I think we need to move on from him. He showed so much promise last season, not sure what to think..

Re: Skins vs Carolina Pre Game
 

[quote=ethat001;1158999]So the worst team in past 15 seasons on third downs? 2011 San Diego Chargers, when Barry was the LB coach. Joe Barry's teams in the past 10 years have some of the WORST third down defenses in history -- and although he didn't always make the D calls, you've got to believe he clearly wasn't the solution. He's used to mediocrity and his experience and everything he's learned in the NFL has been about BAD DEFENSE. Not sure why his career makes us trust him.

Detroit - 2007 - 45% (30th in league)
Tampa Bay - 2009 - 40% (23rd in league)
San Diego - 2011 - 49% (32nd in league)
San Diego - 2012 - 42% (29th in league)
San Diego - 2013 - 40% (21st in league)
San Diego - 2014 - 43% (25th in league)[/quote]

Wow, I mean just wow?! Bloody hail no wonder Barry struggles with OT he's never seen or learned a solid strategy for defending third down? :(

Re: Skins vs Carolina Pre Game
 

[quote=Bangee7;1158997]And while we're at it, let's cut down on letting the other team score!

The discussion is [B]what does it take to make that happen[/B]?

What has to happen to get off the field on 3rd down? Just get a new Def Coord & we get massively better?

Our secondary (even with Josh Norman) seems to have regressed. Our safeties suck (again), Breeland & Dunbar regressed and Fuller doesn't seem like he's improving. Is Perry Fewell doing his job well enough?

I put some blame on McL for not addressing the d-line more strongly. Going in with basically career backups as starters (Goldson, Hood, RJF) is hardly a formula for success in the NFL.

I just think our def problems need more talent before we can judge Barry fairly. But, hey, if he's the one telling McL that he could make those pieces work, then I would agree that he should go.

I'm not close enough to know if that's the case though.

-Hail.[/quote]

We are simply victims of hype, just like fans of most NFL teams. In May the experts gave our draft an A or B+ and we fell for it. Our expectations for the D were too high and thinking the addition of
Norman alone wasn't going to boost it, especially when Breeland has regressed. Our defense is full of guys that are really backups. I will give a pass to our rookies.

Re: Skins vs Carolina Pre Game
 

I cant wait for a new DC honestly. Can.... Not.. . Wait.

Re: Skins vs Carolina Pre Game
 

[quote=Meks;1159004]I cant wait for a new DC honestly. Can.... Not.. . Wait.[/quote]

We said that with Haslett.

I can't wait to improve the talent on D first and foremost.

Re: Skins vs Carolina Pre Game
 

[quote=MTK;1159005]We said that with Haslett.

I can't wait to improve the talent on D first and foremost.[/quote]

Agreed.
The only thing I don't like from Barry is that I feel like he's not bringing his guys to play hungry, hard, the energy seems to be low on that side of the ball.

Other than that I'm not mad at his playcalling, he's doing a decent job considering the level of talent at his disposal.

As bad as they look this defense is pretty good in some areas, including sacks number.
And that's good for this week: carolina's right tackle is weak, last week he got humiliated on several plays by the chargers.

Re: Skins vs Carolina Pre Game
 

[quote=FrenchSkin;1159006]Agreed.
The only thing I don't like from Barry is that I feel like he's not bringing his guys to play hungry, hard, the energy seems to be low on that side of the ball.

Other than that I'm not mad at his playcalling, he's doing a decent job considering the level of talent at his disposal.[/quote]

Cooley was on the radio earlier this week talking about how guys are consistently confused, out of position and missing assignments.

He suggests/implies that Barry may be putting more checks and contingencies on his players than they can digest. This has two negative effects. 1. missed assignments. 2. slow play because of thinking

Cooley says his favorite philosophy is to put as much on the players as they can handle e.g. Wade Phillips in the playoffs last year. No two looks were the same against the Pats.

We don't do anything well. He says pick something and play it well rather than playing 4 things poorly.

Re: Skins vs Carolina Pre Game
 

[quote=DYoungJelly;1159007]Cooley was on the radio earlier this week talking about how guys are consistently confused, out of position and missing assignments.

He suggests/implies that Barry may be putting more checks and contingencies on his players than they can digest. This has two negative effects. 1. missed assignments. 2. slow play because of thinking

Cooley says his favorite philosophy is to put as much on the players as they can handle e.g. Wade Phillips in the playoffs last year. No two looks were the same against the Pats.

We don't do anything well. He says pick something and play it well rather than playing 4 things poorly.[/quote]

He's got a solid point (he knows a thing or two about football, doesn't he? ^^), we've seen too many hugely blown coverage for it to be 100% on the players.

I'm wondering out loud ("out writing"?): with our level of talent, how likely it is that opp off coord quickly find a way to expose the defense if they only have a few plays in their book?

Re: Skins vs Carolina Pre Game
 

[quote=FrenchSkin;1159006]Agreed.
[B]The only thing I don't like from Barry is that I feel like he's not bringing his guys to play hungry, hard, the energy seems to be low on that side of the ball.[/B]

Other than that I'm not mad at his playcalling, he's doing a decent job considering the level of talent at his disposal.

As bad as they look this defense is pretty good in some areas, including sacks number.
And that's good for this week: carolina's right tackle is weak, last week he got humiliated on several plays by the chargers.[/quote]

I strongly disagree with your contention that the the effort of the defensive players is unsatisfactory. My observation is that the defensive players do play hard. They don't always play well and we certainly need better, faster players on defense but I don't question the effort.

As for Joe Barry, the problem with Barry is not that he is isn't a capable DC. The problem is that he is not an outstanding DC. If we're going to get to the next level as a team, we'll need outstanding coordinators on both sides of the ball.

Re: Skins vs Carolina Pre Game
 

I haven't seen effort or energy as an issue either. That falls mainly on the players anyway. If you can't get up for playing football you just don't belong here.

Re: Skins vs Carolina Pre Game
 

[quote=MTK;1159005]We said that with Haslett.

I can't wait to improve the talent on D first and foremost.[/quote]

Tis true.. I just wish we had a more inside, in depth look at play calling, esp on 3rd down, to see how the talent we do have, is being used. I also think Breeland needs to wake up i dont know if he's unmotivated or still pissing and moaning over the Norman signing or what, but, its.not uncommon to have the sophomore slump so let's hope it's a small issue... Other D issues... No pass rush 85% of the time, nothing up the middle usually, qbs are hardly ever contained and break easy runs for 1st downs (this is where scheme and play calling gets looked at most IMO) ... oh yea, NO PASS rush or pressure most 3rd downs that I recall.... so i mean. Switching to a more aggressive coordinator could help if we yes, improve some speed and the line on D

Re: Skins vs Carolina Pre Game
 

Everyone blames Barry for the defensive struggles, he's surrounded by a pretty good defensive staff, including 2 former solid DC"s (Fewell and Manusky). You guys don't think he listens to their input? We lack 1 solid DL, S, ILB, pass rusher and we'll be fine. If they fire Barry, we got either Fewell or Manusky to take over.

[url=http://www.espn.com/blog/washington-redskins/post/_/id/29143/joe-barry-doesnt-deserve-a-pass-for-redskins-defensive-issues]Joe Barry doesn't deserve pass for Redskins' defensive issues - Washington Redskins Blog- ESPN[/url]

Re: Skins vs Carolina Pre Game
 

[quote=KI Skins Fan;1159010]I strongly disagree with your contention that the the effort of the defensive players is unsatisfactory. My observation is that the defensive players do play hard. They don't always play well and we certainly need better, faster players on defense but I don't question the effort.

As for Joe Barry, the problem with Barry is not that he is isn't a capable DC. The problem is that he is not an outstanding DC. If we're going to get to the next level as a team, we'll need outstanding coordinators on both sides of the ball.[/quote]

Maybe I'm wrong. This is more of a feeling than an analyzed statement.

I really don't know what stat could give us and idea of how good our pursuit is. For me that's an aspect where talent isn't a factor, just pure motivation to give your best effort on every play.

But maybe part of what I perceive AT TIMES like a little lack of motivation is on, as said by DYoungJelly, Barry asking too much of his players and them hesitating... Hard to tell.

Re: Skins vs Carolina Pre Game
 

[quote=MTK;1159005]We said that with Haslett.

I can't wait to improve the talent on D first and foremost.[/quote]

Exactly, Barry doesn't have much to work with to begin with. Only half our unit is starter worthy. I am in the give Barry one more year camp, but if they did ditch him I wouldn't cry about it.

Re: Skins vs Carolina Pre Game
 

[quote=FrenchSkin;1159031]Maybe I'm wrong. This is more of a feeling than an analyzed statement.

I really don't know what stat could give us and idea of how good our pursuit is. For me that's an aspect where talent isn't a factor, just pure motivation to give your best effort on every play.

But maybe part of what I perceive AT TIMES like a little lack of motivation is on, as said by DYoungJelly, Barry asking too much of his players and them hesitating... Hard to tell.[/quote]

Interesting comment. That is why I think some of us in here are for giving Barry another year, maybe even two to get some bona fide starters in here, especially on the line and at both LB, CB, and S positions. The overall quality of the unit is below average. Barry just doesn't have the horses to get the job done. Still, you have to adapt to what you have to work with and make changes to your schemes to maximize the unit's effectiveness. Thus, Barry definitely has to shoulder a lot of the blame for the current state of the defense.