Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

I understand why there is a lot of gloom and doom sentiment around here. I would have to be a blind optimist to think that we don't have some serious problems. The running game is the worst we've seen in years, the passing game has sputtered, we've lost Jansen and Rogers for the season, Thomas might not come back until mid-December, we barely beat Miami and Arizona, and we got demolished by the Patriots.

With all that being said, I strongly believe that this team will make the playoffs and here is why. Yes, the defense got demolished by the Patriots, but what defense wouldn't? The defense is stout and, with the emergence of Rocky McIntosh and the additions of guys like Laron Landry, London Fletcher, and even David Macklin, this defense will return to form next week. The offensive line is really banged up, but I cannot help but think that time itself and Buges' coaching up will help [I]improve [/I]things (even if the O-line doesn't become a source of strength). Portis, Moss and Betts, IMO, are not the Hall of Famers we want them to be, but they are too good to continue playing like they have. Does anyone really think Portis, Moss, and Betts can play any worse? Jason Campbell is young and has just 14 starts under his belt and [I]should[/I] improve with time. Finally, after this Sunday we [I]should[/I] be 5-3 in a weak NFC with a schedule that isn't a cakewalk, but isn't exactly tough.

So, my question to you is, will the Redskins make the playoffs this season?

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

Mark me down as a yes.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

I am also a yes. Our schedule after the Dallas game should help out quite a bit.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

I would say yes as well.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

We had the same poll at 5-6 in 2005. I said yes then and I'll say yes again

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

So why isn't everyone who voted going on record? Weenies. :spank:

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

I'll be the weenie....I really want to see how they respond to last weeks loss before I go on record as saying anything, but if we beat the Jets, than mark me down as a yes. We have too many winnable games left. The only games that I would say we "shouldnt" win are Dallas x2, and @ NYG. So thats 3 more losses, which would put us at 10-6. I would hope we could beat Dallas at home, especially if its meaningful, but based on what we've seen so far, they're a bit better than us. Not saying they're/Giants like Patriots level good, but I think we should win every other game...i stress SHOULD.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

As a wildcard, but yes.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

[quote=Sheriff Gonna Getcha;371653]So why isn't everyone who voted going on record? Weenies. :spank:[/quote]

Next time make it a public poll so we can see who voted for what

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

[QUOTE=Mattyk72;371656]Next time make it a public poll so we can see who voted for what[/QUOTE]

Yup, my bad.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

i voted yes... but only if rock cartwright moves to number two on the depth chart behind cp... He is explosive on special teams. and betts should be traded because he cannot break a tackle....

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

Well I'm going to come out and say that I said no.

I said no because the Giants are looking like a whole new team after week 3. The realistic chances of our team winning the division playing like we are aren't very good. We would have to go beat the Giants in New York and Dallas probably twice just to be in contention.

We will probably be one of those 3-5 teams fighting for that wildcard spot and I just can't see us winning out in the end. Especially seeing as we don't play a team besides the Bucs who look like they would be fighting for the wildcard spot too. So our fate in the end will almost definitely be decided by another team.

For the record though I sure as hell hope we do make the playoffs. I just can't help but express my doubts.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

We're 1-1 in our division so I don't really know. Our O looks like trash and key injuries are starting to creep on us on both sides of the ball. Honestly, it's kinda stupid to say yes before we even played Dallas and the Giants one more time.

Ask this question when we've played and won couple of more games against divisional foes and my answer would be yes.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

Put me down for a Yes, as I look at the remaining schedule, I predict 3 losses at most finishing at 10-6 which is good enough for the post season.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

Yes we will make the playoffs. Look who we are competing against for the final wildcard, assuming New York doesn't collapse again this year (which I don't know how you can assume given their recent history). Detroit, who we have a head to head advantage against, is the toughest foe. I like their team but I am very comfortable going against them down the stretch. Either New Orleans, Carolina, or Tampa Bay, whoever doesn't end up winning that division. Not scared of that challenge. Who else? San Francisco or Arizona? Puleeaze. Chicago? They are done.

If we can merely win a couple tough games I don't see how we can miss out. Yes last week was humbling but we are still good enough to beat anyone in the NFC, imo.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

I say 'yes'. There are no other teams on our schedule that actually fill me with dread. Can we lose more games than we should? Yes. Do we have the personnel that will not let that happen? Yes. As bad as we have been playing, by that I mean given our potential, I think the best is yet to come.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

The key, in my opinion, more so than the Cowboys and Giants games are going to be the games against the other teams in the hunt with us for a wild-card spot. We've already beaten two of them with the Lions and Cardinals. And we have an opportunity to beat two more with the Bucs and Bears.

We need to win the games we're expected to win. Starting this Sunday against the Jets

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

i voted weenie and just need to see more. i think this is a year where there are 2 good teams in the nfc and the rest are all about equal. have to see how the tiebreakers work out and how we fare in our divisional games.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

[QUOTE=Cowell;371664]Well I'm going to come out and say that I said no.

I said no because the Giants are looking like a whole new team after week 3. The realistic chances of our team winning the division playing like we are aren't very good. We would have to go beat the Giants in New York and Dallas probably twice just to be in contention.

We will probably be one of those 3-5 teams fighting for that wildcard spot and I just can't see us winning out in the end. Especially seeing as we don't play a team besides the Bucs who look like they would be fighting for the wildcard spot too. So our fate in the end will almost definitely be decided by another team.

For the record though I sure as hell hope we do make the playoffs. I just can't help but express my doubts.[/QUOTE]

I don't agree, but I respect you for having the cajones to say what you think. I think one can make a good case for us not making it, I'm just not buying it until we lose to a team like the Jets.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

Ok, I did vote no.

Upon second thought I think that I should have voted yes. In our next 9 games I think we will beat the Jets, Buccaneers, Bills, Bears, Vikings, and Cowboys.
That means we will split our games with the Eagles and Cowboys, and lose to Giants again.

That will put us at 10 - 6 and we should be able to make it into the playoffs with that record and the weak NFC.

Still I don't feel that this team can pull it off the way we have been playing the last couple of weeks. And this isn't just from the Patriots game that I feel this way. I think that this team does not have an identity on offense. Our defense is there, but they will get murdered if they have to be on the field for over half of the game like they have been lately.

I think all of the tools are there for this offense to succeed, but with the injuries at the line, and the inconsistencies in play calling and catching the ball we are going to be very lucky to win 6 of our next 9. But if any team can do that, it would be the same core group that won out two years ago and made the playoffs.

Let all of the flaming begin.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

I said No.

With the Giants at 6-2 and the Cowboys at 6-1, it's going to be very difficult. If we don't move ahead of one of them, I don't see us making the playoffs. I just think our division is too strong.

I do think we'll finish the season with a winning record, and probably make 10-6, but that might not be enough.

I hope I'm wrong.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

I hope I'm wrong, but I'll go on record as a "No". Here's why:

1) OL is injured and not very good.
2) Portis is not hitting what holes are there. IMO he's either hurt or mentally checked out from this team.
3) Our WRs are poor at best
4) Our offense has no identity, the playcalling is too predictable and some flat out bad playcalls for the game situations we've been in have been made.
5) Campbell will still make young QB mistakes and he's not very good in the three step game. He looks good in Play-action and 5-7 step (when we can protect and a receiver gets open). But the quick passing game should be our best option with a banged up OL.
6) Our defense is good but doesn't scare anybody. To overcome all the offensive problems we need a "dominant" defense (Bears '06, SB Ravens or SB Tampa). This defense, while solid, cannot carry this team.

Here's how I beleive the playoffs will unfold:

Divison winners will be: Dallas, Green Bay, New Orleans and Seattle. NY Giants (unless they tank) will be one Wildcard. That leaves us, Detroit, Tampa Bay, Carolina and Arizona fighting for the last wildcards.

Here's how I see the rest of the season: Should be Wins: BUF & NYJ, Probable Losses: Tampa Bay (in Tampa), Dallas (at Dallas), NYG (in NY, we haven't won there in the last 3 years). Could go either way: CHI, PHI, MIN, Dallas (at home). So before the games going either way we are 6 - 6, if we split we're 8 - 8 and that's not getting us in. If we are 9 - 7 we have a chance if the tiebreakers go our way, but Tampa's schedule is easier than ours and Detroit is 5-2. Our playoffs will probably be determined on Nov. 25th in Tampa Bay.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

I voted no. I just dont see how we can rebound after this week. I dont think the offense is very good. Our injuries are too great to make it. I think we will probably loose some close games to teams we should beat. I hope I am wrong. :frusty: But I guess there is always next year.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

It really doesn't matter what other teams do. We have to win 6 out of the remaining 9 games to make the playoffs. Put it another way, we can only afford 3 losses. What in gods name makes you think Gibbs and Co have a better than 50% chance of winning 6 more games?

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

Thanks sandtrap there as putting down a yes. I see us splitting with the boys this year. I also think we should be 10-6 at the end of the year. Getting Thomas back in december might also propell us to a couple of wins in the playoffs. That is as long as we don't have many more injuries. Our D will be back next week. We have Macklin and Pearson P. as nickel guys. Also we need Smooot back in the lineup. O-line time to Gell this week.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

they will make it, a lot, because of the weak NFC, we will be seeded 6

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

I don't think we will be able to make the playoffs. Ideally, I'd love to see how the team as a whole rebounds from this loss, but I think our team is too inconsistent to make the playoffs. Typically, we seem to play up and down to our competition (those close games regardless of our opponents, except the Patriots, is a bad sign -- not a good one). The skins won't be out of many games, but they will be keeping games close which can mean unlucky losses, etc.

I just think the Giants are really hot although they typically tail off as the season goes on, Dallas looks great, and Philly looks great against Detroit!

Our playoff chances really depend on the NFC South. I think it's pretty safe that GB will win the north, and the west is terrible so we don't have to worry about a wildcard. Carolina and TB will fight it out for that division, and the loser has a good shot at the 2nd wild card.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

check me in with a yes we will make the playoffs. given the weak nfc..i dont see how we wont. and it all starts sunday against the jets. Its time to either put up or shut up. I do think our offense is suffering from the injury bug. Its time open up this so called 700 page play book and do something to get this offense jump started. But on a side note i cant believe the folks over at nfl network for reshowing that performance from sunday. I thought they showed the best games from the previous weekend...what the hell were they thinking about? and finally GO COLTS on sunday.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

I am typically an optimist, but I'm getting a rotten vibe. I gotta go with no.

I think teams in the last few weeks have exposed our weaknesses on offense. The secret is out that you can get in Campbell's face up the middle, because Rabach is not 100% and Fabini stinks. The secret is also out that we only run to the left. Nobody respects our ability to run right. I don't respect it either.

I don't think we win either of the Cowboy games, and I can't see us beating BOTH the Giants and Philly. McNabb's looking a lot better lately, by the way. Three more losses within the division will really put us in a bind. We'd need to win every other game left on the schedule.

I'd love nothing more than to be wrong, but I think we come close, but ultimately miss out at 9-7.

PS If we lose to the Jets, our chances of making the playoffs drop to like 10% in my opinion, I'm counting on us beating them.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

I'm not so sure why people are counting us out at 9-7. People must have more faith in the NFC than I do. I'm just not sold on the notion that there are 6 better teams than the Redskins in the NFC.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

[quote=Sheriff Gonna Getcha;371710]I'm not so sure why people are counting us out at 9-7. People must have more faith in the NFC than I do. I'm just not sold on the notion that there are 6 better teams than the Redskins in the NFC.[/quote]

I definitely agree that 9 wins could get someone in. The NFC is just so mediocre.

Whoever makes it to the Super Bowl from the NFC is going to get trounced.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

I'm an eternal optimist, but unless some things change over the course of the next nine games, this is a difficult question to answer. This team has already had to overcome so much adversity which has invarably led to so much inconsistency, it's extremely difficult to predict a possible outcome for this season. I think a lot of things have to go right the rest of the way, including the ability to win close games. It has become painfully obvious that the games we have left on the schedule are going to be close, and hard fought. The four division games left, and the one against Tampa Bay will pretty much decide our season.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

What wildcard teams are going to have 10 wins? The Giants? Probably. Anyone else? Doubtfully. Detroit's got a pretty damn tough schedule. Carolina has the 21st ranked defense and no QB. Arizona won't win 10 games either. In short, our competition sucks.

People might not think we are a playoff caliber team, but find me 6 other NFC teams that are. We don't need to be a top team in the NFL, we need to be a top team in the NFC.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

drew54, do you want me to change you vote in the poll?

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

I voted no. I think we'll end up 7-9 and miss the last wild card spot by a game.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

If we continue to sputter on offense and continue to think that Cover 2 is unbeatable we wont make the playoffs .... but

11/4@ [IMG]http://redskins.com/uploads/graphics/perm/main/AKHICFKCGKCK/jets_logoCOVER.jpg[/IMG] [B]Jets[/B]1pm ET W
11/11vs. [IMG]http://redskins.com/uploads/graphics/perm/main/AKHICFKCGKCK/eagles.gif[/IMG] [B]Eagles[/B]1pm ET ? W
11/18@ [IMG]http://redskins.com/uploads/graphics/perm/main/AKHICFKCGKCK/cowboys.gif[/IMG] [B]Cowboys[/B]4:15pm ET ?
11/25@ [IMG]http://redskins.com/uploads/graphics/perm/main/AKHICFKCGKCK/buccaneers.gif[/IMG] [B]Buccaneers[/B]1pm ET ?
12/2vs. [IMG]http://redskins.com/uploads/graphics/perm/main/AKHICFKCGKCK/BuffaloBillsLogo2.jpg[/IMG] [B]Bills[/B]1pm ET W
12/6vs. [IMG]http://redskins.com/uploads/graphics/perm/main/AKHICFKCGKCK/bears.gif[/IMG] [B]Bears[/B]8:15pm ET W
12/16@ [IMG]http://redskins.com/uploads/graphics/perm/main/AKHICFKCGKCK/giants.gif[/IMG] [B]Giants[/B]8:15pm ET ? W
12/23@ [IMG]http://redskins.com/uploads/graphics/perm/main/AKHICFKCGKCK/vikings.gif[/IMG] [B]Vikings[/B]1pm ET W
12/30vs. [IMG]http://redskins.com/uploads/graphics/perm/main/AKHICFKCGKCK/cowboys.gif[/IMG] [B]Cowboys[/B]1pm ET ? W


We need to win at least 2 or 3 divisional games .. I think we beat Philly @ home and get revenge against the G-Men ... RT should be back for that one and Im thinkin' we steal one from the Cowgirls @ home ... We have offically hit rock bottom after sunday's loss ... but it will only make this team stronger ... Campbell learn a good lesson Sunday ... Hopefully Wade can learn to block ... cuz hes the weak link on the line

12-4 to 10-6

We finish 2nd in the East ... im Hopin'

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

[QUOTE=Sheriff Gonna Getcha;371716]drew54, do you want me to change you vote in the poll?[/QUOTE]

No, I will go on record as a No vote. In some sick twisted way, I hope that me saying no will make me feel like a jackass when they do.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

[QUOTE=drew54;371730]No, I will go on record as a No vote. In some sick twisted way, I hope that me saying no will make me feel like a jackass when they do.[/QUOTE]

Okay, thanks for at least taking a position publicly. But, I hope you're wrong too. :food-smil

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

NFC Playoffs:
1. Dallas
2. Green Bay
3. Seattle
4. Tampa Bay
5. Giants
6. Redskins

IMO.

Re: Will the Redskins Make the Playoffs
 

Yes we make the playoffs. i just have a sneaky feeling this can of whop-ass the pats put on us has pissed Gibbs off, and he is going to open things up a bit. Call me crazy, but Ive been called worse.