Keep 10-Your Call
 

Same idea as the 10 cuts thread. You're Bruce Allen and Dan Snyder has just asked you to tell him which 10 current Redskins players you must keep on your roster. No questions asked. And not to trade them, but to actually keep them

Devin Thomas
Fred Davis
Hunter Smith
Brian Orakpo
Levi Jones
DeAngelo Hall
Kevin Barnes
Derrick Dockery
Edwin Williams
Chris Horton

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Orakpo
Haynesworth
Alexander
Fletcher
Horton
Cooley
Thomas
Mitchell
Campbell
Davis

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Chris Cooley
Fred Davis
Brian Orakpo
Albert Haynesworth
Levi Jones
Devin Thomas
Vinny Cerrato - I want to put him at QB to play behind that playoff caliber Offensive Line he put together.
London Fletcher
Rocky McIntosh
Chris Horton
Marko Mitchell

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Edwin Williams
Brian Orakpo
HB Blades
Carlos Rogers
Chris Cooley
Fred Davis
Jason Campbell
Albert Haynesworth
Lorenzo Alexander
Jeremy Jarmon

...left off Carter only because a switch to the 3-4 would limit his value. Ditto Fletch.

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Chris Cooley
Fred Davis
Jason Campbell
DevinThomas
Albert Haynesworth
Rocky
Orakpo
Carter
Fletch
Hall
Golston
Landry
Horton
Tyron
Barnes
Hunter Smith
Santana Moss (slot)

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

[quote=GTripp0012;644330]Edwin Williams
Brian Orakpo
HB Blades
Carlos Rogers
Chris Cooley
Fred Davis
Jason Campbell
Albert Haynesworth
Lorenzo Alexander
Jeremy Jarmon

...left off Carter only because a switch to the 3-4 would limit his value. Ditto Fletch.[/quote]

Rogers? Why? (just curious)

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Orakpo
Haynesworth
Cooley
Davis
Thomas
Moss
Dockery
Horton
Carter
Fletcher

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Not really understanding the Levi Jones picks. I'd keep him as opposed to not keeping him, but he's going to be useless by November of next year either way. Seems like, especially after tonight, we're not a better team with him than we are without him.

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

[quote=Ruhskins;644332]Rogers? Why? (just curious)[/quote]If I'm rebuilding the secondary, I can't let him get away. Need to bring back people who challenge receivers.

At this time next year, my list could include Barnes and not Rogers, but in the absence of more information, Rogers is really the only desirable player in my secondary. Admittedly, it's a unit that needs a lot of work.

All concerns about his age still apply.

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

[quote=artmonkforhallofamein07;644331]Chris Cooley
Fred Davis
Jason Campbell
DevinThomas
Albert Haynesworth
Rocky
Orakpo
Carter
Fletch
Hall
Golston
Landry
Horton
Tyron
Barnes
Hunter Smith
Santana Moss (slot)[/quote]

Keep 10. Keep 17. Same difference

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

There's a lot more than 10 I'd keep but many of them would not be in the same roles. Like Moss...if I have to keep him at WR1 go ahead and move him to my 10 I'd cut list. If I can switch him to slot then he can play for me. Williams and Jones...they'd be fine as backup linemen to me.

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

This is possibly the most depressing thread in the history of my time here.

It is just such a clear indicator of how bad it is.

We have a few young keepers, but it's fugly ugly when you look at it this way.

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Campbell, I think you'd be justified in leaving him off this list. But I think just having Snyder NOT nosing around for a quarterback would be worth it's weight in gold to the rebuilding process.

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Keeping Jones because I wanted one tackle. But realistically I probably take Jarmon ahead of him, or Haynesworth (if I didn't have him on my list already)

Depending on where we draft I want Campbell to return as our starter. And even if we do bring him back as the starter, I'd still want to get a good young backup

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

[quote=SmootSmack;644343]Keeping Jones because I wanted one tackle. But realistically I probably take Jarmon ahead of him, or Haynesworth (if I didn't have him on my list already)

Depending on where we draft I want Campbell to return as our starter. And even if we do bring him back as the starter, I'd still want to get a good young backup[/quote]Heard that, if Shanahan was the coach, Colt McCoy would be the draft target in the second round after an OT in the first. This move would get multiple thumbs up for me, if only for it's value to actually having depth at the QB position.

We probably could open this one up to more than ten guys. It's not that I want to get rid of Devin Thomas or Malcolm Kelly (or Anthony Montgomery, or Chris Wilson, or Chris Horton, or Marko Mitchell), but they certainly haven't shown enough to waste one of ten spots on.

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Cooley
Davis
Orakpo
Fletcher
Haynesworth
Hall
McIntosh
Thomas
Carter
Campbell (only because I hate our other options at QB for next year)

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

[quote=GTripp0012;644344]Heard that, if Shanahan was the coach, Colt McCoy would be the draft target in the second round after an OT in the first. This move would get multiple thumbs up for me, if only for it's value to actually having depth at the QB position.[/quote]

I would second this.

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Orapko
Haynesworth
Campbell
Cooley
Davis
Thomas
Landry (If we move back to SS he would be okay)
Horton
Flecther
Rogers (If he would quit biting on the double moves he would be okay)

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

[quote=GTripp0012;644344]Heard that, if Shanahan was the coach, Colt McCoy would be the draft target in the second round after an OT in the first. This move would get multiple thumbs up for me, if only for it's value to actually having depth at the QB position.[/quote]

I think what you heard was that Kiper said he sees McCoy as a 2nd round pick, who he compares to Jake Plummer. And Plummer had some great years under Shanahan. But that's not the same as Colt is being targeted by Shanahan in the 2nd round.

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Mr. Allen is keeping:
Marko Mitchell
Quinton Ganther
Marcus Mason
Devin Thomas
Fred Davis
Chris Cooley
Levi Jones
Jeremy Jarmon
Chase Daniel
Jason Campbell for a two year extension. and still draft a QB in the second round.

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

[quote=SmootSmack;644353]I think what you heard was that Kiper said he sees McCoy as a 2nd round pick, who he compares to Jake Plummer. And Plummer had some great years under Shanahan. But that's not the same as Colt is being targeted by Shanahan in the 2nd round.[/quote]Yeah, it was something like that. Well, someone has to start the rumor!

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Jason Campbell
London Fletcher
Devin Thomas
Fred Davis
Hunter Smith
Brian Orakpo
DeAngelo Hall
Kevin Barnes
Derrick Dockery
Chris Horton

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

1. Orakpo (DUH)
2. HAYNESWORTH
3.Thomas
4. Davis (Beast)
5. Hall
6. Dockery
7. A.Carter
8. Horton
9. BRUCE ALLEN LOL
10. Mike Shanahan

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

[quote=GTripp0012;644334]Not really understanding the Levi Jones picks. I'd keep him as opposed to not keeping him, but he's going to be useless by November of next year either way. Seems like, especially after tonight, we're not a better team with him than we are without him.[/quote]
agreed

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Orakpo
Jarmon
Thomas
Davis
Haynesworth
Cooley
E. Williams
Smith
Barnes
Hall

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Haynesworth
Portis
Hall
Cooley
Orakpo
Carter
Landry
Thomas
Moss
Kelly
Davis
Hunter
I know its 12 but I'd keep them

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Brian Orakpo
Albert Haynesworth
Andre Carter
Rocky McIntosh
Fred Davis
Devin Thomas
London Fletcher
Laron Landry (at SS)
Justin Tryon
Chris Cooley

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

thomas
hall
orakpo
haynesworth
carter
fletcher
campbell
davis
mitchell
jarmon

honorable mentions to cooley, dockery, barnes, blades

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Hall
Haynesworth
Gano!!
Hollywood Thomas
Davis
Cooley
Ganther
Yoder
Horton - I never realized how sorely he was missed in the secondary until I just took in the fact how long he's been on IR. Doughty and Landry are no good in coverage. :doh:
Moss (But FFS, NOT as the #1 receiver. Put him in the slot)

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

[quote=SUNRA;644354]Mr. Allen is keeping:
Marko Mitchell
Quinton Ganther
Marcus Mason
Devin Thomas
Fred Davis
Chris Cooley
Levi Jones
Jeremy Jarmon
[B]Chase Daniel[/B]
Jason Campbell for a two year extension. and still draft a QB in the second round.[/quote]

Am I missing something here? :confused:

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

1) Orakpo- shows the most performance in his FIRST year in the NFL.
2) Thomas- provides the "young spark" we need desperately at the wide out position.
3) Davis- like Thomas/Orakpo shows promise at a position we'll need to be a strong team
4) Haynesworth- 100million. nuff said.
5) Fletcher- doesn't matter who is coming at him, the tackle is made.
6) Cooley- we all know cooley for what he is. no need to give a reason.
7) H.B. Blades- a Fletcher clone who will pick up where London left off after retirement.
8) Landry- i'm upset with his coverage but put him at SS and QB's fear him. make them throw away from him, that alone takes away half the field.
9) McIntosh- he's been in the system for a few years now and understands what to do. young enough to contribute for years to come but old enough to teach the rookies.
10) Hall- in the NFL you NEED a superior corner and currently the redskins roster's BEST cb is Hall (even if he does start a few fights here and there)

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

haynesworth
carter
orakpo
fletcher
hall
horton
campbell
moss
devin thomas
fred davis

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Brian Orakpo, 100%
Albert Haynesworth, begrudgingly
Andre Carter
Jason Campbell
Chris Cooley
Fred Davis
Rocky McIntosh
Laron Landry, provided he moves back to strong safety
Devin Thomas
Malcolm Kelly

[B][U]Alternate Keepers[/U][/B]
Chris Horton
Kareem Moore
H.B. Blades
Jeremy Jarmin
London Fletcher
Lorenzo Alexander

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

1) Orakpo
2) Haynesworth
3) D. Thomas
4) Davis
5) Fletcher
6)

Ok I give up, I honestly can't name 10 "gotta have 'em at any cost" kind of guys.

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Cooley / Davis - could be the best TE duo in the NFL next season.
Smith / Gano - love the leg strength of the kicker
Thomas / Kelly - Could be a very good WR tandem in the league
Haynesworth - if used properly could be a beast and help Carter and Orakpo get a ton of sacks.
Jason Campbell - I really think we can win with this guy. He is tough, works hard, and when presented a decent(not even good) oline he can produce and produce very effectively.
Dockery / Reinhart - I think could be two very effective Guards for us.
Orakpo - no explination needed
Hall - gets burned sometimes, but I think if we continue to use our Dline and get pressure - he could lead the league in picks.
Cant think of anyone else.

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

1. Orakpo
2. Phat Albert
3. Dock
4. Devin Thomas
6. Hall
7. JC
8. Fletcher
9. Fred Davis
10. Cooley

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

1. JC
2. Moss
3. Thomas
4. Davis
5. Orakpo
6. Fletcher
7. AH
8. D-hall
9. Landry
10. Dockery

More will stay but those guys have made plays even when we're 4-10. We know LL needs a true FS to be as good as he was the first 10 gms in '07.

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

Orakpo
Haynesworth
Jarmon
Fletcher
McIntosh
Kevin Barnes
Devin Thomas
Fred Davis
Dockery
Hunter Smith

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

[quote=artmonkforhallofamein07;644331]Chris Cooley
Fred Davis
Jason Campbell
DevinThomas
Albert Haynesworth
Rocky
Orakpo
Carter
Fletch
Hall
Golston
Landry
Horton
Tyron
Barnes
Hunter Smith
Santana Moss (slot)[/quote]


Total fail.

Re: Keep 10-Your Call
 

sackpo
cooley
davis
thomas
mitchell
horton
phat al
jarmon
hall
fletcher, to be a solid leader