Would You Rather...
 

Pretty simple question: Would you rather take a team with Blache and Campbell or Haslett and McNabb?

As much as I like the addition of Mcnabb to this team, I cant remember a time when the defense was this bad. So which would you rather have?

Re: Would You Rather...
 

Why not McNabb/Shanny but with Blache? I know people didn't like his "boring" defenses, but they didn't look this bad week after week.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

I'd really almost prefer Zorn and McNabb at this rate. Sigh.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=DynamiteRave;739633]I'd really almost prefer Zorn and McNabb at this rate. Sigh.[/quote]

HA, that really wasnt a option.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

I think the switch will be really beneficial over time, but it will also take time to get there.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=WaldSkins;739639]HA, that really wasnt a option.[/quote]

Then Haslett/McNabb. McNabb at least puts us in a position to win. JC is doing in Oak what he should've been doing here. Riding the pine.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=WaldSkins;739621]Pretty simple question: Would you rather take a team with Zorn and Campbell or Haslett and McNabb?

As much as I like the addition of Mcnabb to this team, I cant remember a time when the defense was this bad. So which would you rather have?[/quote]

K, its not that bad. Zorn and Campbell was pretty f*cking bad. Ill take McNabb and Haslett

Re: Would You Rather...
 

Good question. McNabb and Kyle are definite upgrades. What Mike, Kyle, and Jim need to realize is that what was successful for other teams isn't a determination to totally scrap what we already do well. Let's see more power running, working some stretch plays in. Need I mention the defense? You can play more aggressively (exotic blitzes) while preserving the 4-3 schemes.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

doesn't matter what combo you take we would still suck

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=chewman;739666]doesn't matter what combo you take we would still suck[/quote]

+100

Re: Would You Rather...
 

Go back to a 4-3 which fits our personnel. We have the best 3-technique lineman in the league. Somewhere, Greg Blache is laughing his ass off.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

Haslett and McNabb for sure, but on the condition that Shanahan gets Haslett to stop effing around with this BS defense.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=GMScud;739680]Haslett and McNabb for sure, but on the condition that Shanahan gets Haslett to stop effing around with this BS defense.[/quote]

I'd rather have J. Gray or Mike Zimmer along with a 4-3 defense along with McNabb.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=Ruhskins;739721]I'd rather have Jim Gray or Mike Zimmer along with a 4-3 defense along with McNabb.[/quote]

Did you mean Jerry Gray? Who they should have promoted to DC.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=Chico23231;739652]K, its not that bad. Zorn and Campbell was pretty f*cking bad. Ill take McNabb and Haslett[/quote]

Blache and Campbell's first 3 games were 2-1.

Haslett and McNabbs's first 3 games are 1-2.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=SFREDSKIN;739723]Did you mean Jerry Gray? Who they should have promoted to DC.[/quote]

Yup, that's what I meant. And by the way, I remember you being one of the few protesting the Mike Shanahan move. One more loss and you can probably give us the ol' "I told you so".

Re: Would You Rather...
 

The only issue I have with Shanahan is his love for players who work hard. Look I have nothing but respect for a guy like Lorenzo Alexander, but he is not the guy you put on the field when the game is on the line.

Philip Buchanon also brought a little bit of the Detroit secondary over to the Redskins and with any luck changes will be made this week.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=Ruhskins;739736]Yup, that's what I meant. And by the way, I remember you being one of the few protesting the Mike Shanahan move. One more loss and you can probably give us the ol' "I told you so".[/quote]

Can you say Jim Harbaugh? That's who they should have hired and someone will. If the 49ers continue to screw up they should fire Singletary and jump all over Harbaugh.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

Anything with the words and combination of Jason campbell VS something else..I always go for the Something else.

Doesn't matter...Chuck Norris and Jason Campbell VS Bruce Lee and Pee wee Herman= Lee and Herman

George Washington and Jason Campbell VS B.Obama and M.Obama...got to go with Obama's...([B]that was tough call[/B])

Titanic,Avatar and Jason Campbell VS Amazon women on the moon,Death wish 4 and the bridge on the river kwai...you know the answer!

1963 stingray Corvette,1967 Mustang and Jason Campbell VS 1984 Ugo,any year of the Ford Taurus and a 1988 Pinto...give me the Ugo,taurus and Pinto baby!!

Seriously,I wouldn't change anything, if it meant we had JC back...

As bad as we were tonight,we were still more exciting than last season...
But Haslett needs to get his act together for sure!!

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=IrMitchell;739741]Philip Buchanon also brought a little bit of the Detroit secondary over to the Redskins and with any luck changes will be made this week.[/quote]

Like I said a while back Buchanon never should have made this team, it was a mistake to get rid of Tryon.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

Campbell and Blache (and let's not forget Zorn) were 4-12 last year. **** that.

I know y'all want instant gratification, but please. Those guys are gone for a reason. We want a turnover creating 3-4 and a balanced Mcnabb led shanny attack. Give it a few seasons (seriously). Then we'll talk.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

And, IMHO, it's really not the coaches, in the end. We just do not have the talent. I'm sorry folks, but that's the truth. We've got a few good players, but how many all-pros do we have? We do not exactly strike fear into the hearts of our opponents.

Thanks again, Vinny!

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=JWsleep;739756]And, IMHO, it's really not the coaches, in the end. We just do not have the talent. I'm sorry folks, but that's the truth. We've got a few good players, but how many all-pros do we have? We do not exactly strike fear into the hearts of our opponents.

Thanks again, Vinny![/quote]

The players were not ready to play against the Rams. No heart, no fire, but plenty of penalties and other bonehead errors. That is on the players and on the coaches and has little to do with talent.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

Blache was crappy too. Landry stunk and we gave up bomb after bomb.
We also were gashed often enough on the run.

Not much difference.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=JWsleep;739752]Campbell and Blache (and let's not forget Zorn) were 4-12 last year. **** that.

I know y'all want instant gratification, but please. Those guys are gone for a reason. We want a turnover creating 3-4 and a balanced Mcnabb led shanny attack. Give it a few seasons (seriously). Then we'll talk.[/quote]

The problem with waiting is that mcnabb isn't under contract after this year. Why would he want to resign with a rebuilding club at this point in his career. Also it was a dumb idea switching this club to a 3-4 after the defense wasn't that bad last year.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

we are cursed and we will be cursed for a long time
so lets just put things in perspective and be satisfied with becoming the new lions of the NFL.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=Bushead;739642]I think the switch will be really beneficial over time, but it will also take time to get there.[/quote]

Time!!....That's a word Redskin fans know nothing about. This coaching staff will be rediculed and talked about unmercifully just like the previous ones, if the team continues to lose games. We've seen this so many times before.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

At this point I'd rather shoot myself.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=Lotus;739772]The players were not ready to play against the Rams. No heart, no fire, but plenty of penalties and other bonehead errors. That is on the players and on the coaches and has little to do with talent.[/quote]

You know what Lotus?.....If Shanahan is half the coach he's been credited with being, surely he's come to the realization by now that he inherited a crappy tean. He's going to have to work through the growing pains it's going to take to procure a winning roster.

One thing I've noticed that seems to be missing from Shanahan's demeanor is a little fire and demand for accountability. At the end of last night's post-game press conference he sounded as if he was ready to go pop a cork. No emotion when your team continues to puts on these dismal performances. Going forward, it will be interesting to see just how committed we'll remain to a work in progress.

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=WaldSkins;739730]Blache and Campbell's first 3 games were 2-1.

Haslett and McNabbs's first 3 games are 1-2.[/quote]

Lol, I think you're totally throwing the concept of sample size out the window.
[IMG]http://wattsupwiththat.files.wordpress.com/2010/08/cherrypicking.jpg[/IMG]

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[QUOTE] Originally Posted by WaldSkins
Blache and Campbell's first 3 games were 2-1.

Haslett and McNabbs's first 3 games are 1-2. [/QUOTE]

Blache and Campbell's Division record=0-6
Haslett and McNabb's Division record=1-0

and that's what matters to me...
We beat Philly next week and we are 2-2 with a 2-0 division record and a 2-1 conference record

and back in 1st place.
lets all take a step back and breathe a little people...

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=aceinthehouse;739748]Anything with the words and combination of Jason campbell VS something else..I always go for the Something else.

Doesn't matter...Chuck Norris and Jason Campbell VS Bruce Lee and Pee wee Herman= Lee and Herman

George Washington and Jason Campbell VS B.Obama and M.Obama...got to go with Obama's...([B]that was tough call[/B])

Titanic,Avatar and Jason Campbell VS Amazon women on the moon,Death wish 4 and the bridge on the river kwai...you know the answer!

1963 stingray Corvette,1967 Mustang and Jason Campbell VS 1984 Ugo,any year of the Ford Taurus and a 1988 Pinto...give me the Ugo,taurus and Pinto baby!!

Seriously,I wouldn't change anything, if it meant we had JC back...

As bad as we were tonight,we were still more exciting than last season...
But Haslett needs to get his act together for sure!![/quote]

:funnypost

Re: Would You Rather...
 

[quote=diehard;740016]:funnypost[/quote]

One time, his "something else" was JaMarcus Russell. It's in his posting history.