Quote:
|
Originally Posted by #56fanatic
Peyton is awesome, no doubt. But with only 1 good receiver he could possibly struggle. Vick is overrated. I might get blasted for that one. Vick is a good player, I just dont see where is worth all the hype. He is explosive, great arm, not very accurate and I would like to see how good Atlanta would be with out the great running game they have.
|
I'm not sure if Manning is good because he's surrounded by other amazing players, or if the other players are good because they have Manning. From watching almost all the Colts games this season, I'm leaning toward the former.
Manning is playing at a level that is beyond anything I've ever seen or heard about. He basically runs that offense himself. His audibles are almost always perfect, he manages that team and directs the plays like nobody else in the league. I think the guy is playing football on a mental level that is in another universe compared to any other QB.
It's the little things he does - the constant hurry-up offense wears the defense out, and he gets 1-2 "12 men on the field" penalties on the other team per game because he's so alert and catches them off guard. Defenses get run ragged and can't even substitute.
And that's just his managing - take a look at his arm. His throws are just phenominal. Yeah, you can argue that he has all day with that offensive line giving him protection, but I think that's due in large part to the fact that opposing defenses are terrified to blitz him. He goads the defense into showing him their blitz early, audibles to the perfect counter-play (and does it perfectly, it seems, 90% of the time) and then makes them pay for the blitz.
Is manning helped by the likes of Harrison, James, Clark, Wayne and an incredible defense? Absolutely. But I firmly believe Manning is the key ingredient in that system that makes the team what it is.
Call me crazy, but I'd trade any player on this 'Skins team, heck I'd trade any 10 players on this team for Manning. His dedication and intelligence is contageous and I think he has an amazing ability to make those around him great players. Trade anyone or any group of guys for him and build a new team around his talent. Unfortunately that'll never happen, and a guy like Manning only comes along once in a lifetime.
But hey, this is a fantasy thread and I can dream. While I'm dreaming, might as well talk about this dream I have about Carmen Electra and Denise Richards...