[Schneed10]

On one hand I can see the logic of trying to extend him nice and early; JLC says that these two execs think Campbell is going to be a very good one. If you're operating under the assumption that Campbell's going to be a very good QB, the kind of QB you'd be comfortable having as your long-term starter, then it makes sense to lock him up early. Having not yet proven himself, we could get him at a bargain compared to what he'd cost once he proves himself to be a worthy franchise QB.

Of course you're assuming he's going to be good. It's a tough call either way. Do you let him prove himself, then pay out the nose to keep him? This way you pay a lot, but you can be comfortable that you've got your answer at QB. Or do you save some money and pay him now, taking the chance that he won't pan out? Tough decision.