Quote:
Originally Posted by Crazyhorse1
Ramsey threw for 5669 yards in the equivalent of 22 games. He did it for a team that didn't assign enough pass blockers as policy and had bad receivers, the best being Rod Gardner, who couldn't catch the ball and was nicknamed 50-50.
Brunell had 5021 yards in the equivalent of 33 games and was throwing to Cooley and Moss (when Moss was a top threat) and the OL was tough.
Campbell has thrown for 2817 in 15 games, far off Ramsey's pace, inspite of being blessed with better receivers (at least last year.)
|
But that doesn't really argue Matty's point that if you had to rate them, solely on W/L and QB rating on what they had done, it breaks down like Brunell, Campbell, and then Ramsey.
Then you gave different objective evidence that is far more misleading than QB rating and W/L combined. Yards/G doesn't really tell us anything without more information, which because it works against your argument, you can't really give here.
You also completely ignored the presence of Laverneus Coles, and oversimplified the rest of the argument.
Advantage, Matty.