Commanders Post at The Warpath - View Single Post

Schneed10 · 12-04-2007, 02:21 PM

Jason Campbell's had a lot of good games for us, and makes a lot of great throws. But I think this highlights the fact that we're still talking about a young QB who needs time to develop.

I took NFL QB stats, and added together INTs and Fumbles Lost. Campbell leads the NFL in fumbles lost at the QB position. This combined total, essentially amounting to turnovers, was then calculated on a per-game basis.

Here's where Campbell ranks:

Name ,Team, TO PG
Trent Dilfer ,SFO, 2.17
Brian Griese ,CHI, 1.83
Eli Manning ,NYG, 1.75
Damon Huard ,KAN, 1.6
Jason Campbell ,WAS, 1.58
Drew Brees ,NOR, 1.5
Jon Kitna ,DET, 1.5
Philip Rivers ,SDG, 1.5
Vince Young ,TEN, 1.45
Rex Grossman ,CHI, 1.43
Kurt Warner ,ARI, 1.4
Tony Romo ,DAL, 1.33
Carson Palmer ,CIN, 1.33
Marc Bulger ,STL, 1.33
Derek Anderson ,CLE, 1.25
Jay Cutler ,DEN, 1.25
Peyton Manning ,IND, 1.17
Ben Roethlisberger ,PIT, 1.17
Daunte Culpepper ,OAK, 1.14
Kellen Clemens ,NYJ, 1.14
Matt Schaub ,HOU, 1.09
Brett Favre ,GNB, 1.08
Matt Hasselbeck ,SEA, 1.08
Donovan McNabb ,PHI, 1
Chad Pennington ,NYJ, 1
J.P. Losman ,BUF, 1
Kyle Boller ,BAL, 0.9
Tom Brady ,NWE, 0.67
Joey Harrington ,ATL, 0.67
Jeff Garcia ,TAM, 0.45
David Garrard ,JAC, 0.33

Fumbles lost, at least with QBs, is an indicator of line play as much as the QB play. But one of my frustrations with Campbell is that he should be feeling the rush and doing a better job of securing the ball when someone's bearing down on him. That's definitely the part of his game that needs the most improvement.

I think he'll improve over time and be a good one for sure, but this is just kind of a reality check to anyone who thinks JC is our savior today or even next season.

12-04-2007, 02:21 PM	#1
Schneed10 A Dude Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: Newtown Square, PA Age: 46 Posts: 12,458	Campbell's Shortcoming Jason Campbell's had a lot of good games for us, and makes a lot of great throws. But I think this highlights the fact that we're still talking about a young QB who needs time to develop. I took NFL QB stats, and added together INTs and Fumbles Lost. Campbell leads the NFL in fumbles lost at the QB position. This combined total, essentially amounting to turnovers, was then calculated on a per-game basis. Here's where Campbell ranks: Name ,Team, TO PG Trent Dilfer ,SFO, 2.17 Brian Griese ,CHI, 1.83 Eli Manning ,NYG, 1.75 Damon Huard ,KAN, 1.6 Jason Campbell ,WAS, 1.58 Drew Brees ,NOR, 1.5 Jon Kitna ,DET, 1.5 Philip Rivers ,SDG, 1.5 Vince Young ,TEN, 1.45 Rex Grossman ,CHI, 1.43 Kurt Warner ,ARI, 1.4 Tony Romo ,DAL, 1.33 Carson Palmer ,CIN, 1.33 Marc Bulger ,STL, 1.33 Derek Anderson ,CLE, 1.25 Jay Cutler ,DEN, 1.25 Peyton Manning ,IND, 1.17 Ben Roethlisberger ,PIT, 1.17 Daunte Culpepper ,OAK, 1.14 Kellen Clemens ,NYJ, 1.14 Matt Schaub ,HOU, 1.09 Brett Favre ,GNB, 1.08 Matt Hasselbeck ,SEA, 1.08 Donovan McNabb ,PHI, 1 Chad Pennington ,NYJ, 1 J.P. Losman ,BUF, 1 Kyle Boller ,BAL, 0.9 Tom Brady ,NWE, 0.67 Joey Harrington ,ATL, 0.67 Jeff Garcia ,TAM, 0.45 David Garrard ,JAC, 0.33 Fumbles lost, at least with QBs, is an indicator of line play as much as the QB play. But one of my frustrations with Campbell is that he should be feeling the rush and doing a better job of securing the ball when someone's bearing down on him. That's definitely the part of his game that needs the most improvement. I think he'll improve over time and be a good one for sure, but this is just kind of a reality check to anyone who thinks JC is our savior today or even next season. __________________ God made certain people to play football. He was one of them.