Quote:
Originally Posted by Mattyk72
Personally I'm hesitant to put him in the great category just yet. He's simply too inconsistent.
|
Agreed, I'd rank 'em like so:
1) P Manning
2) T Brady
3) B Favre
4) D Brees
5) B Roethlisberger
6) C Palmer
7) T Romo
8) D McNabb
9) M Hasselbeck
10) J Garcia
If you can't make top 5 of active players, you can't be considered GREAT. On that list above, I see 3 great ones. All others are varying degrees of good - very good.