Originally Posted by redskinsgirl
I ask you to name every "subpar" QB in the playoffs not every QB.
You didn't answer my questions. You and Buch. never explained why teams with subpart QB play still managed to make the playoffs. All you said was that Collins, Flacco,Ryan, and Ben were better than JC even though they had similar stats to JC. They didn't throw alot of TDs so how were there teams able to average over 20 pts a game??
The only thing Buch said is that those teams averaged more than 13 points a game in the second half of the season.
Neither one of you explained how those four teams were able to average more than 13 points a game? Those four teams QBs were throwning about same amount of TDs that JC was throwing.
This isn't about being a JC fan or Brennan fan. I like JC, Brennan, and Collins. i wish all three could start. I think the skins would have still finished 8-8 regardless who started. You missing the point. The point is just changing QB is not going to make the skins a better team without making improvements in other areas. There are four teams who offenses(passing) were as pathetic as the skins, but still got to the playoffs. Their QBs didn't throw a ton of TDs. They were conservative QBs. They didn't play like Brady. The type of QBs you both hate. You and Buch. made it seem like if JC would have thrown just a couple more TDs than the skins would have been in the playoffs. Look at all the teams who QBs threw a ton of TDs and still missed the playoffs. A team needs more alot more than great QB play to get to the next level. The skins had a #4 defense who couldn't score a TD off a defensive turnovers. There is something wrong when a team defense is ranked number #4 and hasn't scored a TD off a defensive turnover. All the teams in the playoffs had at least scored a touchdown from a defensive turnover.
A couple of more questions I would like answered.
How does Cooley lead the redskins in TDs in 07 and got barely one in the 08 season?? It was the same QB throwning TDs so what happened???
How come the minute Moss gets injured the offense seems to all of sudden cease to exist? Review 06, 07, and 08 seasons. Look at the Lions game in 08where Moss pulled his hammy. Things for the offense started to go downhill from there.
Better yet how come teams like Steelers, Giants can lose key players and don't miss a beat? When the skins lose just one key player things start to fall apart?
How come the skins defense ranked 8th in 07, but scored 4 TDs off defensive turnovers?? Didn't the skins fourth ranked defense couldn't produce a TD from a defensive turnover. Please explain that one to me.
How come by game eight everyone watching a skins game could predict exactly what play Zorn/Smith was going to call on 2nd and 3rd down?
Since you want to bring up the Dallas game, if Moss would have caught the pass Campbell threw in double coverage, than the skins probably would have won that game. The pass was a little overthrown, but it was catchable and he should have caught it. The Dallas loss was really due to bad coaching.
Everyone on here saying JC does deserve some of the blame, but his isn't solely responsible for the skins collaspe. Coaching, DL, OL, receivers, & special teams need too get the blame also.
Look at all the Steelers game last season. They had similar problems to the skins: injured RB, bad oline, QB didn't throw over 20 TDs, but yet they still managed to average 21 ppg and even win a superbowl. Big Ben held the ball too long, checkdown, etc. He did alot of the things you complained JC did, but look how Tomlin put Ben in better situtations than Zorn put Cambpell in.
|