[Paintrain]

Originally Posted by FRPLG

He starts for every single one of them except maybe Seattle if Hasslebeck is healthy. Not a single doubt.

It seems to me that the JC argument breaks down into 2 camps mostly.

1) Thinks he could be a good QB given the right line and tools around him. This group sorta sub-divides into the "That's not good enough versus That is perfectly fine" sub-argument.

2) Thinks he is the worst QB ever. Has never shown anything to make us think he could be an adequate NFL QB. Thinks he's a backup on teams that currently have zilch at QB.

Obviously I'm in the first group and lean to the "perfectly fine" side.

The second group...I don't know what Redskins games you've been watching. I'm not even sure you all have a great grasp of what it takes to win in the NFL. Or maybe I am crazy.

Well one of the second group member said earlier in the thread that with other QB's that are having similar years to JC that we'd be a 8-9 win team right now so what does that tell you?