Commanders Post at The Warpath - View Single Post

offiss · 04-21-2005, 04:49 PM

Are we to believe that Gibbs traded away next years #1 for a mediocre QB? especially when the QB pool next year is much more talented than this one. If Smith and Rogers were in last years draft they probably wouldn't have been drafted until the second rd. neither 1 of them are better than the top 5 last year, [Is it me or does A.Smith look like the second coming of Heath Shuler?] I will tell you this the QB situation in this draft is the same as when Shuler and Dilfer were coming out, and neither ever panned out, and these 2 will probably never do anything significant in the NFL, and Campbell is rated behind them, amazing! No one had Campbell going in the first rd and now that we make a trade for another 1st rd pick all of a sudden he's 1st rd material?

Everyone say's Gibbs doesn't like young QB's, so we pass up on franchise type QB's last season to draft a mediocre QB this year, and we give up a #1 next season when there will be better QB's avail. to overpay for Campbell this season, this kid is not a great college QB, he is not a phenomenal
athlete, and is probably 3 years away from seeing the field, and we are to believe that Gibbs is going to take on a project like Campbell when in all liklyhood he's done after his 5 year's are up.

It sounds like to me that the media is saying just about anything to create a story, every rumor started is because they saw a player at redskin park or a player we visited as if we haven't visited a multiple of players, my thought is their getting nothing from management and aren't to happy with that so they are needling management with falsehoods and rumor after rumor like they did a few day's ago with Vinny.

There are scouts who believe Campbell was a product of superior talent this season, and thats the reason his stats increased so much this year from his previous years.

If Gibbs draft's this kid with the #25 it will prove he knows nothing when it comes to judging unproven talent, which would explain why he's so in love with free agency, it's much easier to evaluate established talent you just have to pay more for it, I am probably getting ahead of myself here but I was saying the same thing last year when he was targeting Brunell and we all know how that worked out!

04-21-2005, 04:49 PM	#69
offiss Registered User Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: sparta, new jersey [ northern jersey ] Age: 61 Posts: 3,097	Re: Ramsey's last days as a Redskin Are we to believe that Gibbs traded away next years #1 for a mediocre QB? especially when the QB pool next year is much more talented than this one. If Smith and Rogers were in last years draft they probably wouldn't have been drafted until the second rd. neither 1 of them are better than the top 5 last year, [Is it me or does A.Smith look like the second coming of Heath Shuler?] I will tell you this the QB situation in this draft is the same as when Shuler and Dilfer were coming out, and neither ever panned out, and these 2 will probably never do anything significant in the NFL, and Campbell is rated behind them, amazing! No one had Campbell going in the first rd and now that we make a trade for another 1st rd pick all of a sudden he's 1st rd material? Everyone say's Gibbs doesn't like young QB's, so we pass up on franchise type QB's last season to draft a mediocre QB this year, and we give up a #1 next season when there will be better QB's avail. to overpay for Campbell this season, this kid is not a great college QB, he is not a phenomenal athlete, and is probably 3 years away from seeing the field, and we are to believe that Gibbs is going to take on a project like Campbell when in all liklyhood he's done after his 5 year's are up. It sounds like to me that the media is saying just about anything to create a story, every rumor started is because they saw a player at redskin park or a player we visited as if we haven't visited a multiple of players, my thought is their getting nothing from management and aren't to happy with that so they are needling management with falsehoods and rumor after rumor like they did a few day's ago with Vinny. There are scouts who believe Campbell was a product of superior talent this season, and thats the reason his stats increased so much this year from his previous years. If Gibbs draft's this kid with the #25 it will prove he knows nothing when it comes to judging unproven talent, which would explain why he's so in love with free agency, it's much easier to evaluate established talent you just have to pay more for it, I am probably getting ahead of myself here but I was saying the same thing last year when he was targeting Brunell and we all know how that worked out!