Quote:
Originally Posted by Mechanix544
This thing is too open to opinion. I think you lose too much in translation, and with 4 different people, you get 4 different ratings.
|
I don't think that is true.
I'm sure there are written parameters for grading what they wee.
Heck, I've graded the same game as a friend of mine.
Without ever consulting the parameters before hand.
Our breakdown of what we saw on the film was almost the same.
I trust that ESPN takes the stat seriously enough to be football honest.
My main problem with the old QBR all stats were created equal.
A QB could fumble and throw a pick 2 get his team down by 2 scores.
He might put up good stats via the old QBR because he might hit a couple of meaningless touchdowns against prevent but the fact that his own poor play to start the game was the reason he accumulated the stats in the first place is lost.