Quote:
Originally Posted by donofriose
I would disagree. There is a big difference between RG3's consistency and Geno Smith's consistency. Also intangibles RG3 definitely has the edge. Both on and off the field. I can guarantee there will not be three rookie quarterbacks starting in the playoffs. As far as QB talent, there is a huge difference between this years draft and last years draft. Last year you had the Heisman winner with a great arm and great intangibles, the QB who could have been a first round pick the past two years, and an underrated QB who was overlooked due to his height. This year you have a QB who could have been a top 10 pick last year but fell off badly and proving that he really was not that good, a QB who lost 5 straight games when he had Tavon Austin and Bailey as receivers, a QB who underachieved at FSU but is shooting up boards because of his "talent".
There is a huge difference between Geno Smith and RG3, and a huge difference between the quarterback classes.
|
You can put two of those five straight on geno for sure, but not the other three, wv had one of the worst defenses in the country last year, stedman was out during a lot of that stretch and there was no reliable third receiver and no reliable running game. I don't think geno is worthy of the number one overall, but I'm fairly certain hell be a solid qb in the league if he can get his mind right.