Redskins vs Giants GameDay Thread

[mlmdub130]

Originally Posted by Gary84Clark

Their dislike of RG3 is based on an irrational belief this is a timing offense a la Peyton Manning or Tom Brady.

What offense in the NFL is not based on timing? Thinking that any offense in the NFL isn't based on timing is kind of irrational.

[skinsfan69]

The td call back on Griffin was the correct call. Shitty rule but the refs got it right. I'd be more worried about at happened after that. Moss is a dumbass. He should be cut. You're a vet and you should know better. Then you go scoreless in the 2nd half with more wr's running wide open and special teams issues. Not going win many games doing that. Same old Deadskins.

[Gary84Clark]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

The td call back on Griffin was the correct call. Shitty rule but the refs got it right. I'd be more worried about at happened after that. Moss is a dumbass. He should be cut. You're a vet and you should know better. Then you go scoreless in the 2nd half with more wr's running wide open and special teams issues. Not going win many games doing that. Same old Deadskins.

Disagree it was not a pass does not matter what happened to the ball once he was across the plane and reestablished possession, touchdown.

[Lotus]

Originally Posted by Gary84Clark

Their dislike of RG3 is based on an irrational belief this is a timing offense a la Peyton Manning or Tom Brady.

Jay Gruden has flat-out described his offense as a timing offense.

Are you saying that you know more about Jay Gruden's offense than he does?

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

The td call back on Griffin was the correct call. Shitty rule but the refs got it right. I'd be more worried about at happened after that. Moss is a dumbass. He should be cut. You're a vet and you should know better. Then you go scoreless in the 2nd half with more wr's running wide open and special teams issues. Not going win many games doing that. Same old Deadskins.

Yeah it was. I wasnt able to see it until just a few hours ago, but he clearly is fumbling the ball away as he crosses the line and by the time there is any control he is out of bounds. He never possessed the ball at or beyond the goal line.

[spAtt]

Originally Posted by Gary84Clark

Disagree it was not a pass does not matter what happened to the ball once he was across the plane and reestablished possession, touchdown.

I agree easy TD call. But you know it doesn't even fucking matter at this point in the season. We still would have lost with that second half performance.

[REDSKINS4ever]

Originally Posted by spAtt

I agree easy TD call. But you know it doesn't even fucking matter at this point in the season. We still would have lost with that second half performance.

The TD reversal changed the entire complexion of the game. I doubt if the NYG would have won if not for that bad call.....the defense did well against the NYG run game....but our leaky secondary continues to get scorched. Maybe it's the personnel. Amerson and Breeland got beat by Beckham.....

[DirtBagZ]

Originally Posted by REDSKINS4ever

The TD reversal changed the entire complexion of the game. I doubt if the NYG would have won if not for that bad call.....the defense did well against the NYG run game....but our leaky secondary continues to get scorched. Maybe it's the personnel. Amerson and Breeland got beat by Beckham.....

Agreed the call changed the game and was BS, since he had possesion as a RB before he crossed the plane of the goal line.

Counter factual, the lowly Bicarri Rambo, who was cut, by our Genius coach, just had a two interception game. So I disagree, the biggest problem on this team, is coaching, and the lack of having scheme to suite the players, combined with poor execution and stupid penalties, which are also signs of bad coaching.

[donofriose]

How was that a bad call? He lost the ball about two yards before crossing the goal line and never established possession again.

[MTK]

He bobbled the ball but regained control as he crossed the goal line. Should have been a TD.

[skinsfaninok]

The skins played against the refs yesterday not just the Giants. That was one of the most embarrassing called games in a long time

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

He bobbled the ball but regained control as he crossed the goal line. Should have been a TD.

It didnt look like he regained control to me but I have to watch it again.

[donofriose]

Originally Posted by punch it in

It didnt look like he regained control to me but I have to watch it again.

I agree with you. I think the rule says once you lose the ball, which he did, he has to maintain possession similar to a catch.

[irish]

It wasnt a TD. The refs were correct.

The problem is that Moss decided to be the dumbass he is and make a bad situation worse. His 30 or so yards of penalties tacked on to the kickoff made it certain NY would try an onside kick. Everyone knew it was coming and somehow the Skins still let NY get the ball. Once NY scored I knew the Skins would lose.

If I was the coach Moss wouldn't play this week vs Philly.

[MTK]

I don't even agree that he lost control. The ball shifted around but he kept both hands on it and by the time he crossed the plane he had full control. BS rule.