2006 Free Agent Cornerbacks

[That Guy]

Originally Posted by onebum

ok i guess, but I said that I don't think he's a number 1 corner.

His stats and your 5 teams doesn't change my opinion. I don't think he takes away his part of the field, I don't think he is on the top shelf of CBs, and I don't think he's a top CB. U may think so, no big deal that we disagree on this.

I don't think he's a #1 corner because I don't think he's a number 1 corner. A statline and your 5 teams doesn't mean I think he's a top CB, so my opinion remains.
---
I'm not going to debate this anymore, not because i'm irratated or anything, I'm just not going to debate a non-skins player and if i think he's a top CB. You are speaking in certainty as if there is a list with no question, and I'm speaking of my opinion...this started with my opinion. Apparently my opinion is wrong because of his stats and your 5 teams, but it remains my opinion. Therefore I don't think he's a top CB.

so a guy that is the #1 corner on his team and would be #1 for at least 5-10 other teams isn't a #1 corner (even when in fact he really is)?

I speak with certainty because when you look at the bills depth chart, he's their #1 corner. you may not think he's a shutdown corner, but how many of those really exit in the league? maybe 5? being elite and being top 32 are two different things, but i'd like to see you're list where he ranks #33 or below in NFL CBs.