Vince Young overrated?

[jsarno]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

But I think the point (or a point) to be taken from that is that he's showing improvement in that category. Which is what you want to see from a young QB

Yeah, that is very true. I'm an advocate of the comp% stat, and he has improved dramatically there.
However, while he's gone up in certain catagories, he's gone down in several as well.

If he had one bad game in the 4th...say he throws two int's next week in the 4th and ends up with a 35 rating, that would drop his rating to around 80 if not worse in the 4th. So while he is showing a temporary improvement in a couple catagories, his inconsistancies for his career might show that it's a fluke. Time will tell. But you are correct that he is showing improvement in certain catagories right now.