Who are your Top 5 players on Offense and Defense in the NFL?

Originally Posted by steveo395

....because you put him ahead of Tom Brady?

Bradys injury last season dropped him to 3 on my list. Warner has played great in Arizona with really no running game and somehow got the Cards to the Super Bowl. If Brady comesback and puts up numbers anywhere close to 2007 he will move up ahead of Warner.

I would of put Brees ahead of Brady also but he makes mistakes that costs his team at times. His numbers are great though with a injury prone offense. I can understand someone putting Brees anywhere from 1-4 on their list.

Originally Posted by Daseal

Defense:
1. N. Asimough (Butchered his name. CB from the Raiders.)
2. M. Williams (DE from the Texans)
3. J. Peppers (DE Carolina)
4. D. Dockett
5. P. Willis

You would rank Darnell Dockett ahead of Albert Haynesworth?