Eli Manning vs Jason Campbell

[53Fan]

Originally Posted by Giantone

LOL.............yeah BUT he didn't.You can find one thing in every game,if the Pats D holds on to Eli, if the ref blows the whisle,if,if,if Tyree drops the ball...............but if didn't happen.I'll take an"under performing" #1 ...who can take a team as young as the Giants with the changes he keeps having thrown at him...anytime them some loser who has good stats and can't win a pressure game to save his life(not JC).
The team must believe in the QB ....the Giants do,do the rest of the Skins believe in JC?

I haven't heard or seen anything to make me think they don't. Giantone has a point. You can always point to different things in a game that would have changed the outcome. Eli has a ring and Jason doesn't. Doe's that mean he's a better QB though? Using that logic, Eli is better than Dan Marino ever was. I think it's too early in their careers to make a clearcut choice. Hopefully we'll at least have a little clearer picture after this year..... Or maybe we won't.