Around the NFL: Week 7

[NC_Skins]

Best QB in NFL history.






...and his teammates trolled him.

Gfycat - jiffier gifs through HTML5 Video Conversion. Fast, simple gif hosting without size limits.

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by NC_Skins

Best QB in NFL history.

Statswise, yes, SB wins, no. There have been many great QB's to say one is better than the other.

[NC_Skins]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Statswise, yes, SB wins, no. There have been many great QB's to say one is better than the other.

Teams win SBs, not individual players. Comparing Peyton's teams to the likes of Montana's 49ers or Brady's Patriots is laughable to say the least.


I've watched QBs since the 80's and I have never seen a QB do the things that Manning has done (or probably will ever do). I"d put Montana right behind Manning though. If a future hall of famer safety (Rodney Harrison) says he's the best he's ever played against, I'd take his word with some serious weight. Also note, Harrison pointed out that he had played against Brady as well.

[Hijinx]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Statswise, yes, SB wins, no. There have been many great QB's to say one is better than the other.

That is like saying Trent Dilfer(1 SB win) belongs in the HoF, but not Dan Marino(0 SB wins).

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by Hijinx

That is like saying Trent Dilfer(1 SB win) belongs in the HoF, but not Dan Marino(0 SB wins).

You are going to say this guys weren't great

Sammy Baugh
Bart Starr 5X championships
Johnny Unitas
Brett Favre
Joe Montana
John Elway
Otto Graham
Tom Brady

[Chico23231]

Third home loss sparks turmoil in Bears locker room | ProFootballTalk

wow

[NC_Skins]

LOL

https://twitter.com/shanenfl/status/523980955263205376

[Hog1]

Positives:
I am unafraid to watch the halftime highlights during the Denver SF game.....

[spAtt]

Originally Posted by Hog1

Positives:
I am unafraid to watch the halftime highlights during the Denver SF game.....

You are correct. We won there for nothing we did will be shown!

[Gary84Clark]

It's all opinion and I choose Montana. Peyton you have to spend too much money to get the pieces he needs.

[NC_Skins]

Originally Posted by Gary84Clark

It's all opinion and I choose Montana. Peyton you have to spend too much money to get the pieces he needs.

How so? Peyton isn't asking for any of these pieces. One of the main reasons Bill Polian was fired is because he neglected the defense. That's the thing. Peyton makes these WRs much better than what they are. He puts them in a position to succeed and flourish. Do you see Decker putting up the numbers he did in Denver? Nope. Most of these guys (Darius/Julius/Decker) were here before Peyton Manning. How come they weren't doing 1/2 of what they are doing? The QB play.

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

They were great but in the NFL you are judged by winning SB's. Manning is a notorious SB choker.

No, only fans and media do stupid shit like that.

[NC_Skins]

The problem with Super Bowls is that it comes down to 1 game. Do you think Kobe Bryant or Michael Jordan have the rings they do if the NBA title was a one game elimination?

Hell no.


There is too much that can happen in one game, and it relies on 30+ other players to do their job.

I suggest you look at Vanderjagt's playoff kicking percentage. Look at Vinateri's. See how many games were lost/won by said kicking. Again, SO many factors in winning a super bowl to hold that against a player.

If you want to use SBs, Timmy Smith was a better RB than Barry Sanders. Yeah...sounds stupid doesn't it?

[Dirtbag59]

Ironically Manning and Luck are now tied for the league lead in TD passes (19). Then again Luck also has 2 rushing TD's

Huh huh, league lead. Thats like a tongue twister huh huh.

[SFREDSKIN]

Manning 11-12 in playoffs, 1-2 in SB's tell that to Montana, Starr, Unitas and Brady.

[NC_Skins]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Manning 11-12 in playoffs, 1-2 in SB's tell that to Montana, Starr, Unitas and Brady.

It's a team game. HERR DERRR

Like I said. Manning has to rely on 30+ other players to do it as well, and quite frankly he hasn't had the same support as many of these guys you list. Same with Dan Marino. One game eliminations isn't something you base a person's worth on. To do so is short sighted and narrow minded to say the least.