Plusses and Minuses vs. Browns

[MTK]

The author of the article gives him credit for making a nice play with the back shoulder pass. So what about it is garbage exactly?

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

The author of the article gives him credit for making a nice play with the back shoulder pass. So what about it is garbage exactly?

He says KC "struggles against starters." I believe that KC has top passing games in each of his three seasons ( Cleveland 12, Atlanta 13, Philly 14) despite not being the full time starter. He's making it sound like the guy is Cult Brennan. He's had plenty of success against full time starters. Sure he's had his struggles, like every QB that has 9 starts.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

He says KC "struggles against starters." I believe that KC has top passing games in each of his three seasons ( Cleveland 12, Atlanta 13, Philly 14) despite not being the full time starter. He's making it sound like the guy is Cult Brennan. He's had plenty of success against full time starters. Sure he's had his struggles, like every QB that has 9 starts.

When you look at him preseason vs regular season, what other conclusion can one make?? Sure he's had some big games, he's also had some absolutely dreadful ones. Overall the article was pretty accurate and fair in pointing out what he does well and what he needs to improve on. I don't see where he's saying he can't improve, or comparing him to a scrub like Brennan.

[JoeRedskin]

So many folks have such strong opinions on their choice in the RGIII / KC issue it just blinds them to objective critique of either.

Whatev's ... haters gotta hat.

[That Guy]

Originally Posted by JoeRedskin

So many folks have such strong opinions on their choice in the RGIII / KC issue it just blinds them to objective critique of either.

Whatev's ... haters gotta hat.

they're both bad.

do i win?

[WillH]

Originally Posted by JoeRedskin

So many folks have such strong opinions on their choice in the RGIII / KC issue it just blinds them to objective critique of either.

Whatev's ... haters gotta hat.

I believe it's hatters gotta hat.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by JoeRedskin

So many folks have such strong opinions on their choice in the RGIII / KC issue it just blinds them to objective critique of either.

Whatev's ... haters gotta hat.

I just need one of these guys to step on the field, show growth and lead this team. I don't care who it is...I just wanna win.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

When you look at him preseason vs regular season, what other conclusion can one make?? Sure he's had some big games, he's also had some absolutely dreadful ones. Overall the article was pretty accurate and fair in pointing out what he does well and what he needs to improve on. I don't see where he's saying he can't improve, or comparing him to a scrub like Brennan.

And this is my point. You could say this about every NFL starter in the NFL. They all "struggled" within those first two years of starting. Why would a 4th rounder be any different?

[MTK]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

And this is my point. You could say this about every NFL starter in the NFL. They all "struggled" within those first two years of starting. Why would a 4th rounder be any different?

So how is is hating on the guy? Or comparing him to Brennan?