Code Red all HANDS on deck Skins vs Saints prediction thread

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by 30gut

Wow. If we lose Griffin, Almo and Jay and McVay that would really suck from a team building perspective.



Imo Jay and McVay are played a large role in Griffin and Alf being gone.

Oh come on - Griff had ample opportunity. He is as good as gone and that ship sailed months ago. How in the hell is Gruden responsible for the fact that Griff cannot read defenses?

[30gut]

Originally Posted by punch it in

Oh come on - Griff had ample opportunity. He is as good as gone and that ship sailed months ago. How in the hell is Gruden responsible for the fact that Griff cannot read defenses?

The HC/playcaller always plays a role in the success or failure of their players.

[DYoungJelly]

Originally Posted by 30gut

The HC/playcaller always plays a role in the success or failure of their players.

Based on that logic, fire Bill Calahan?

[30gut]

Originally Posted by DYoungJelly

Based on that logic, fire Bill Calahan?

That wouldn't be based on what I said at all. But its a free country...

[DYoungJelly]

Originally Posted by 30gut

That wouldn't be based on what I said at all. But its a free country...

Right, but the coaches play a huge role in what we're seeing on the field?

He is the run game coordinator, play suggestor, guru according to all the reports.

The run game has sucked since the Rams game.

Originally Posted by 30gut

Reputation is great. Production is better.

Are you talking about Callahan or McVay?

[30gut]

Originally Posted by DYoungJelly

Right, but the coaches play a huge role in what we're seeing on the field?

He is the run game coordinator, play suggestor, guru according to all the reports.

The run game has sucked since the Rams game.

I'm pretty sure you already know that your wild leap to conclusion doesn't follow at all from what I said.

First of all no where do I suggest firing a coach. Second I said the HC/playcaller plays a role and Callahan is neither. He has no power or authority over which plays are called he's merely a 'suggestor' as you put.

Originally Posted by DYoungJelly

Are you talking about Callahan or McVay?

Who? McVay.
You're the one talking about Callahan.

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by 30gut

The HC/playcaller always plays a role in the success or failure of their players.

So does the player. In Roberts case that is 100%. When and if he goes elsewhere - we will see that. I will always love him for 2012 but he is a bust. Sad but true.