Around the nfl week 14

[30gut]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

So 2012 draft qbs - Luck, Griffin, Tannehill, Weeden, Osweiler, Wilson, Foles, Cousins.

Are we all buying Wilson as the best out of that crew? Is Cousins better than Luck at this point, equal?

I've always bought that, even in 2012. Imo Wilson has been underrated for awhile.

Now Cousins vs Luck? Not sure if serious.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by 30gut

I've always bought that, even in 2012. Imo Wilson has been underrated for awhile.

Now Cousins vs Luck? Not sure if serious.

I am dead serious about Cousins v Luck. Now to be fair I have been a negative Nelly on Luck from day 1. Saw Gruden's QB carousel show with him and decided that he wasn't what the Luck cult was selling. I had started to turnaround on him, but then this year happened.

Look at Cousins this year, vs Luck's 2013(2nd year starter) stats

..................Cousins.....Luck
Games ...........13,.........16
Completion % 69.2,......60.2
Yards / Game 254.2,....238.9
TD %..............4.0,....... 4.0
INT % .............2.4, ......1.6
40_+ yds .........6, ........ 9
Sacks ..............23,....... 32
Rating .............93.2, .... 87.0

stats are from NFL stats page.

I'm not saying Kirk definitely is better than Luck, but I have never held Luck on any type of pedestal either.

edit: I hate white space formatting in these!

[30gut]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

I am dead serious about Cousins v Luck. Now to be fair I have been a negative Nelly on Luck from day 1. Saw Gruden's QB carousel show with him and decided that he wasn't what the Luck cult was selling. I had started to turnaround on him, but then this year happened.
I'm not saying Kirk definitely is better than Luck, but I have never held Luck on any type of pedestal either.

Trust me, I've never been in on all the Andrew Luck hype.

Luck has played good football, he no doubt has a recklessness to his game (just look at his INTs) and he came into the league with weapons on offense and day 1 on a team completely and totally centered around facilitating his success.

I watch a ton of football and there was a period of time when Tannehill and Luck (even by PFF bunch of trolls!) were just about even, PFF actually had Tannehill higher then Luck in their top 10 QBs. (which caused casual fans to meltdown). With that being said Luck was uber productive in 2014 43 total TDs 5,000+ yards of total offense.

Net/net Luck and Cousins imo shouldn't be mentioned in the same sentence. And when it comes to this list I don't see why anyone would exclude any part of a players career. So when it comes to Foles you can't just throw out 2013 anymore then you can discount Griffin's career based on 7 games with Jay.