Panthers v. Skins Gameday Thread

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

Thank you defense...And thanks god for Peterson.

Alex Smith...we gotten taken on that trade folks. Looks like I was right again

Who would you rather have had?

Keenum? Bradford? Fact is Smith doesnt lose many games by his play.

And losing fuller hasnt really seemed to hurt our secondary, and we ended up getting our 3rd round pick back.

I am still happy with the trade. Doctson caught some balls Quick and Harris also made some plays.

Bottomline a win is a win.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

Who would you rather have had?

Keenum? Bradford? Fact is Smith doesnt lose many games by his play.

And losing fuller hasnt really seemed to hurt our secondary, and we ended up getting our 3rd round pick back.

I am still happy with the trade. Doctson caught some balls Quick and Harris also made some plays.

Bottomline a win is a win.

Bottomline, Alex smith isn’t very good. And we got at least 2 more years and a cap hit the a year after.

We need CT back pronto, dude was missed today.

[sdskinsfan2001]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

Bottomline, Alex smith isn’t very good. And we got at least 2 more years and a cap hit the a year after.

We need CT back pronto, dude was missed today.

Bottomline, our season is still alive. We needed that real bad. And now also off the schneid against that douchebag QB.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

Bottomline, Alex smith isn’t very good. And we got at least 2 more years and a cap hit the a year after.

We need CT back pronto, dude was missed today.

Again, if you accept Cousins wasnt staying, then the trade was worth it. The 3rd round pick was recouped and Moreau/Dunbar have proven as capable Breeland/Fuller. And AS will grow into the offense. 3-2 losing to NO on moday night and a better than expected Colts and 1st in the NFC East. I will take that from the QB.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

Again, if you accept Cousins wasnt staying, then the trade was worth it. The 3rd round pick was recouped and Moreau/Dunbar have proven as capable Breeland/Fuller. And AS will grow into the offense. 3-2 losing to NO on moday night and a better than expected Colts and 1st in the NFC East. I will take that from the QB.

The trade was not worth it. From what I've seen from Smith, if Colt were in there we'd have more production from that position. Give Colt a low starter salary, bring in a vet and roll with that. Instead we're stuck with his salary for what.. two more years? Sorry but there is no way anyone can sit here and say that Smith is better than Colt in this offense. No way.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

The trade was not worth it. From what I've seen from Smith, if Colt were in there we'd have more production from that position. Give Colt a low starter salary, bring in a vet and roll with that. Instead we're stuck with his salary for what.. two more years? Sorry but there is no way anyone can sit here and say that Smith is better than Colt in this offense. No way.

Hard to take a call for Colt serious. AS is a better qb by far. I think you saw some growth of the offense but i will say it is taking longer than i thought for the offense to sync.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

Hard to take a call for Colt serious. AS is a better qb by far. I think you saw some growth of the offense but i will say it is taking longer than i thought for the offense to sync.

We'll agree to disagree. Smith does nothing for me as a NFL QB. He's fine when there's a running game, the d is holding things down and we're ahead. He can play that game. But against the more explosive offenses we literally have zero chance of winning the game.

Smith can't anticipate wr's breaking open, nor can he throw deep out patters. He can throw to guys that are wide open and inside the hashes. He's easy to defend, just pack middle of the field and make him throw outside the numbers. After 5 games I can see why Andy Reid and Harbaugh wanted someone else.

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

We'll agree to disagree. Smith does nothing for me as a NFL QB. He's fine when there's a running game, the d is holding things down and we're ahead. He can play that game. But against the more explosive offenses we literally have zero chance of winning the game.

Smith can't anticipate wr's breaking open, nor can he throw deep out patters. He can throw to guys that are wide open and inside the hashes. He's easy to defend, just pack middle of the field and make him throw outside the numbers. After 5 games I can see why Andy Reid and Harbaugh wanted someone else.

I could have told you that, saw lots of him here in SF.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

Again, if you accept Cousins wasnt staying, then the trade was worth it. The 3rd round pick was recouped and Moreau/Dunbar have proven as capable Breeland/Fuller. And AS will grow into the offense. 3-2 losing to NO on moday night and a better than expected Colts and 1st in the NFC East. I will take that from the QB.

You take it for now....we apparently don’t think about the future much.

I accept only that we fucked up the cousins situation because we did to a t.

You better hope AP keeps running the ball like he has