Did Gibbs Make the Wrong Call?

[skinsguy]

Originally Posted by offiss

I don't no what to tell you exept I think you learned football in the twilight zone somewhere.

I'm sure that makes sense to only you.

Originally Posted by offiss

I know your struggling hard for contradiction's but trust me there are none other than hilousanations in your mind.

I have no idea what hilousanation is. Is that english from the twilight zone? Didn't have to struggle very hard to find the contradiction. It stuck out as a sore thumb. I can understand not being able to see it when you're reading with your eyes closed.

Originally Posted by offiss

So throwing wouldn't have worked even though running on the #1 defense against the run would have? Our weekest strength against their strongest strength, always a good matchup.

Never said it wouldn't have worked. Stop making things up just to argue. Again, your question comes into play, did you actually watch the game? How many yards did Clinton Portis run on this defense all day? You still haven't told me how many years you've coached in the NFL nor how many Super Bowl appearances and trophies you have won.

Originally Posted by offiss

Further more a role out would have taken advantage of the over pursuit of Rice, in case you didn't notice it worked earlier in the second half.

It might have worked and it might not have worked. It is a bigger risk to role your qb out on that third down play AND to throw the ball. It's idiotic in my opinion. Our strength that day was running the ball.

Originally Posted by offiss

Point out to me the short yardage runs we have made over the last year and a half in crucial situations goal line, and with the game on the line, I find it pointless to look for something that's just not there even though you say it is, please enlighten me. Bears, philli, Tampa, the second dallas game last year, the opening game against tampa last year, just off the top of my head are all games we gave the ball back when a simple first down would have iced the game when a team was within 1 score of tying, or beating us. Didn't we winde up giving the ball back to Dallas the last time we played them with our big comeback?

That is why your argument is a weak one at best. You can't come up with anything that has to do with the present season to fully support your argument. It's last year this, last year that. The only people who care about last year are the ones who live by the old saying, "misery loves company." They haven't got the strength to put down last season and move forward.