Campbell, now!

[MTK]

Originally Posted by TAFKAS

I think the answer is to ask paulskinsfan what we should do, let funandgunner reiterate the decision....and hope that matty doesn't ruin it somehow

Unfortunately my ego wouldn't allow that to happen.

[skinnyfan]

I would love to see Campbell play....let us see what we gave the world up for. I mean, this year is cooked and I do mean well done.....so let us see what the kid has! It will never happen though.

[EXoffender]

Campbell being the 3rd stringer isn't getting many snaps nowadays. So if it soes happen, don't get your hopes up too high.

[celts32]

As long as a winning record is still possible you stick with Brunell. Brunell is not the problem...he fumbles to much but yesterdays prblem was protection. That may have been the worst game of Jon Jansen's life. He was a turnstyle out there...

[VTSkins897]

brunell should finish out the year. as far as next year it's anyones guess. maybe there will be an open competition. i would lean towards brunell starting next yr too though.

[Longtimefan]

Originally Posted by VTSkins897

brunell should finish out the year. as far as next year it's anyones guess. maybe there will be an open competition. i would lean towards brunell starting next yr too though.

Iagree, and maybe JUST MAYBE if we block a little better he could have even more success.

[SUNRA]

Mark Brunell has made the entire league recognize his ability to find the open receiver no matter how difficult the pass. He has been in the top Ten QBs rating all year and has earned the respect of his team mates something Ramsey nor Campbell can do in their stages of development. It is a shame that a fan of the Redskins could be so shallow to call for the replacement of the Brunell when he is the main reason we even have five wins. First the argument was the offense doesn't score enough TD's. Then that became history. Now Brunell is the reason for the loss yesterday and should be replaced. Now who in their right mind......Boy I can't even finish this thread because it's too ridiculous.

[scowan]

I think we are all overacting on Brunell. The reason the Skins are losing is because the "D" can't stop the big play, (or very many plays for that matter) and in the 2nd half Sunday, I blame what I thought was very poor play calling on our inability to come back. There were several series late in the game when Brunell dropped back to pass 3 straight times and had three straight incompletions when we had 2 WRs (thrash and patten) out of the game. Way to go Gibbs, play to our strenghts! And all of those bombs to Taylor Jacobs, were a joke.

[offiss]

Originally Posted by scowan

I think we are all overacting on Brunell. The reason the Skins are losing is because the "D" can't stop the big play, (or very many plays for that matter) and in the 2nd half Sunday, I blame what I thought was very poor play calling on our inability to come back. There were several series late in the game when Brunell dropped back to pass 3 straight times and had three straight incompletions when we had 2 WRs (thrash and patten) out of the game. Way to go Gibbs, play to our strenghts! And all of those bombs to Taylor Jacobs, were a joke.

That's it I had it, no one, and I mean NO ONE, questions Gibbs on this site, he's a hall of famer and has won 3 SB's, how many have you one sir?

[dmek25]

you guys have got to be kidding.i once thought as redskins fans as some of the most knowledgeable fans there are.but after reading some of these posts,i dont know what to think.we are 2 games out of first with plenty of football left(including games with the g men and dallas)and you guys are ready to trash the season?thats exactly what happens if j c comes in.it isnt a slam on him but playing q back is the most difficult position in any sport to excel in,bar none.does anyone remember the last time a rookie q back started for a team and excelled?please refresh my memory if this has ever happened?

[skinsguy]

Originally Posted by dmek25

you guys have got to be kidding.i once thought as redskins fans as some of the most knowledgeable fans there are.but after reading some of these posts,i dont know what to think.we are 2 games out of first with plenty of football left(including games with the g men and dallas)and you guys are ready to trash the season?thats exactly what happens if j c comes in.it isnt a slam on him but playing q back is the most difficult position in any sport to excel in,bar none.does anyone remember the last time a rookie q back started for a team and excelled?please refresh my memory if this has ever happened?

Ben Roethlisberger. But for us, I can't think of anyone who had came in as a rookie and had led us to a winning season. I think when Mark Rypien finally nailed down the starting position, he had already been in the league for a year, maybe two.

[offiss]

Originally Posted by skinsguy

Ben Roethlisberger. But for us, I can't think of anyone who had came in as a rookie and had led us to a winning season. I think when Mark Rypien finally nailed down the starting position, he had already been in the league for a year, maybe two.

Close, He really didn't nail it down until the season he won the SB about 6 seasons, in fact that season was a due or die for him.

[MTK]

[dmek25]

is big ben that good or just a very good fit for an already good team?

[offiss]

Originally Posted by dmek25

is big ben that good or just a very good fit for an already good team?

I believe it's both, he's obviously better than anyone else they have that's for sure.