Chase Young or Three First Round Picks?

[EdmundDorf]

Moving back to 9 is a long way, would need lots of picks

[KI Skins Fan]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

So Ross Tucker said he has heard of a team in the top 10 that is very serious about moving up to #2 in need of a QB, That isn't Miami. Said they have 2 first round picks to offer, so clearly he's talking about the Jags.

Would you take 9 , 20 and their 3rd round pick for #2?

I think I would

Here's what my mock draft looked like if we were to do that trade:


WAS 9. Tristan Wirfs OT Iowa

WAS 20. Denzel Mims WR Baylor

WAS 66. Cole Kmet TE Notre Dame

WAS 73. Matt Hennessy C Temple

WAS 108. Harrison Bryant TE FAU

WAS 142. Jack Driscoll OT Auburn

WAS 162. Harrison Hand CB Temple

WAS 216. Steven Montez QB Colorado

WAS 229. Chris Williamson CB Minnesota

[Number44]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

So Ross Tucker said he has heard of a team in the top 10 that is very serious about moving up to #2 in need of a QB, That isn't Miami. Said they have 2 first round picks to offer, so clearly he's talking about the Jags.

Would you take 9 , 20 and their 3rd round pick for #2?

I think I would

5,18, and 39 from Miami is much better and is the baseline for what the Redskins should accept, IMO. I think JAX would have to up the ante to get the #2 pick. Perhaps 9,20, 42, and a player that fits a Redskins need like a Dede Westbrook would work.

If teams want to trade up, I think the Redskins have to set a high threshold for what it would take, otherwise we should draft the generational talent in Chase Young at #2.

[rocnrik]

With 9 and 20 we get top Wr and OL with 3rd we get TE ... is that worth chase young ? well with young we will have a very very good D and a bad O .. with a trade we could have a above average D and average O..we need help on Offense

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by rocnrik

With 9 and 20 we get top Wr and OL with 3rd we get TE ... is that worth chase young ? well with young we will have a very very good D and a bad O .. with a trade we could have a above average D and average O..we need help on Offense

I think it's worth the look for sure, Chase is great but we have more holes than pass rusher.. Sweat and RK are back as well. We need CB , LT , TE , WR , G.

All more than DE/EDGE right now. If they get an offer like that and turn it down I'd be a little surprised , if they do not get an offer then of course I'm pumped for Chase

[sdskinsfan2001]

Moving all the way down to 9? Pass! We need to come out of the 1st with Chase or Okudah.

We have 6 other picks, FAs, and UDFAs to fill other holes. Get the elite guy with the 1st pick.

[BigHairedAristocrat]

For months, i've been an advocate of trading down. This was under the assumption that "Tua Mania" would take over as he cleared physicals and wow'ed NFL teams at his pro-day and in private interviews and teams would be in a bidding war for the #2 overall pick to secure his services. This was under the belief that the floor of any such trade would be three first round picks.

That is no longer a realistic possibility. No team is going to trade up to #2 for Tua at this point. Miami might not even be comfortable taking him at 5. We might get offers to trade up to 2 by a team that wants Chase Young, as he's just about the more sure-fire thing in this draft, but teams won't give up enough for a non-QB to make it worth our while to pass on him.

Due to corona virus, our path has become crystal clear. We're going to take the best player - the safest player - in the draft and select Young. End of Story.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by BigHairedAristocrat

For months, i've been an advocate of trading down. This was under the assumption that "Tua Mania" would take over as he cleared physicals and wow'ed NFL teams at his pro-day and in private interviews and teams would be in a bidding war for the #2 overall pick to secure his services. This was under the belief that the floor of any such trade would be three first round picks.

That is no longer a realistic possibility. No team is going to trade up to #2 for Tua at this point. Miami might not even be comfortable taking him at 5. We might get offers to trade up to 2 by a team that wants Chase Young, as he's just about the more sure-fire thing in this draft, but teams won't give up enough for a non-QB to make it worth our while to pass on him.

Due to corona virus, our path has become crystal clear. We're going to take the best player - the safest player - in the draft and select Young. End of Story.

I'm not sure teams wouldn't move up for Tua, there is no reason why they wouldn't, especially a team like the Jags who are desperate for a FACE of their franchise. It's possible , not saying I disagree with u.

If we take Chase I'm all in for it

[BigHairedAristocrat]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

I'm not sure teams wouldn't move up for Tua, there is no reason why they wouldn't, especially a team like the Jags who are desperate for a FACE of their franchise. It's possible , not saying I disagree with u.

If we take Chase I'm all in for it

Its all about the medical. What team is going to trade UP for a player who just had a major hip surgery? Teams are not going to want to give up multiple picks to acquire a player who recently had that kind of injury unless their own doctors can examine the player first.

[Number44]

Originally Posted by BigHairedAristocrat

For months, i've been an advocate of trading down. This was under the assumption that "Tua Mania" would take over as he cleared physicals and wow'ed NFL teams at his pro-day and in private interviews and teams would be in a bidding war for the #2 overall pick to secure his services. This was under the belief that the floor of any such trade would be three first round picks.

That is no longer a realistic possibility. No team is going to trade up to #2 for Tua at this point. Miami might not even be comfortable taking him at 5. We might get offers to trade up to 2 by a team that wants Chase Young, as he's just about the more sure-fire thing in this draft, but teams won't give up enough for a non-QB to make it worth our while to pass on him.

Due to corona virus, our path has become crystal clear. We're going to take the best player - the safest player - in the draft and select Young. End of Story.

We are in agreement that if the best offers, if any, we get don't meet a certain threshold ( for you it's 5, 18, and 26; for me it's 5,18, and 39) then we hold what we've got and draft Chase Young. Whether or not a team is willing to pay the price has always been the question. That hasn't changed.

[sdskinsfan2001]

Originally Posted by Number44

We are in agreement that if the best offers, if any, we get don't meet a certain threshold ( for you it's 5, 18, and 26; for me it's 5,18, and 39) then we hold what we've got and draft Chase Young. Whether or not a team is willing to pay the price has always been the question. That hasn't changed.

I hope no one does. Make the draft as simple as possible.

Getting the best player in the draft works 60% of the time every time!

[Number44]

Originally Posted by sdskinsfan2001

I hope no one does. Make the draft as simple as possible.

Getting the best player in the draft works 60% of the time every time!

90% of the game is half-mental.

[NYCskinfan82]

No matter what we do the media will always laugh at us what have we done for the last 20 years we are an easy target. I'm OK with what the media says JMO most of them don't know sh%t anyways and change sides faster than a hooker turning tricks. Take CY unless they give you so many picks you feel embarrassed.

[Pervis_Griffith]

I really want Chase Young.

Adding him to Allen, Payne, Sweat, Ioannidis, and Kerrigan gets me hard.

But .... having said that ...

... if someone wants to give us two 1st rounders this year, plus a 2nd rounder this year, AND a pick in next year's draft (1st or 2nd)? Well ... you have to think about it.

I just don't see anybody even thinking about doing that kind of thing. There's noone in the entire draft being talked about being worthy of all those picks ... except for maybe Chase Young, who is consistently labeled as the best player in the entire draft.

[skinsfaninok]

One of our OL Graders who was a Bengals coach for 23 years insists they are considering taking Herbert in the draft, apparently they loved his workout and chats with him. That would be CRAZY