Chase Young or Three First Round Picks?

[AnonEmouse]

Do we really need lots of help? Not saying we don't but wasn't coaching the biggest issue in recent years?

I mean look at SF. Yes Kittle and Bosa are potential HoF players but it's not like they have a fully loaded roster. The biggest difference maker to that team was getting coaching (though Lynch deserves a lot of credit).

Maybe we shouldn't be too ready to trade away a potential difference maker in exchange for just more picks. Maybe CY isn't what he's made out to be, but there's more chance he is than he isn't. Is there 1, maybe even 2 players lower down the order that offer the potential impact he does? Maybe but unlikely based on the analysis I've seen. Quality over quantity in my book.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by AnonEmouse

Do we really need lots of help? Not saying we don't but wasn't coaching the biggest issue in recent years?

I mean look at SF. Yes Kittle and Bosa are potential HoF players but it's not like they have a fully loaded roster. The biggest difference maker to that team was getting coaching (though Lynch deserves a lot of credit).

Maybe we shouldn't be too ready to trade away a potential difference maker in exchange for just more picks. Maybe CY isn't what he's made out to be, but there's more chance he is than he isn't. Is there 1, maybe even 2 players lower down the order that offer the potential impact he does? Maybe but unlikely based on the analysis I've seen. Quality over quantity in my book.

SF had a damn good offense to help that D stay fresh, we do not have that

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by AnonEmouse

Do we really need lots of help? Not saying we don't but wasn't coaching the biggest issue in recent years?

I mean look at SF. Yes Kittle and Bosa are potential HoF players but it's not like they have a fully loaded roster. The biggest difference maker to that team was getting coaching (though Lynch deserves a lot of credit).

Maybe we shouldn't be too ready to trade away a potential difference maker in exchange for just more picks. Maybe CY isn't what he's made out to be, but there's more chance he is than he isn't. Is there 1, maybe even 2 players lower down the order that offer the potential impact he does? Maybe but unlikely based on the analysis I've seen. Quality over quantity in my book.

San Fran has really nice pieces on defense that was built from the draft and a secondary that benefited sitting in zone coverages.

The ultimate compliment to that defense is the offense system. On San Fran offense its scheme > talent. Oline...good not great, RB...role players, WR...role players...QB...above average...TE...great athletic player who is in a scheme that features the tight end.

That offense is well coach, but it based on a running scheme which allows a defense to sit and rest.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

San Fran has really nice pieces on defense that was built from the draft and a secondary that benefited sitting in zone coverages.

The ultimate compliment to that defense is the offense system. On San Fran offense its scheme > talent. Oline...good not great, RB...role players, WR...role players...QB...above average...TE...great athletic player who is in a scheme that features the tight end.

That offense is well coach, but it based on a running scheme which allows a defense to sit and rest.

Yep and the only reason they sucked the year prior was due to a ton of injuries and their QB1 was out.

[WCommandersfan99]

Give me Chase Young, a new stud wr and all olinemen after that. This would dramatically improve this team. Haskins will kill it was protection. Also our stud tbs (AP, Guice, Love, Mckissic.) If we move Williams, we could be really looking different/improved post draft.