WFT Quarterback Thread - Post SEASON 2021

[GridIron26]

I wouldn't oppose to trading for Carr as long as we are not giving up our 1st round pick

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by GridIron26

I wouldn't oppose to trading for Carr as long as we are not giving up our 1st round pick

That’s what it would take though. He’s been a very good QB for his career and coming off a really good season. What are we picking at 19 that is better than Carr? The only QB that could be left by then is Mac Jones.

[Number44]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

That’s what it would take though. He’s been a very good QB for his career and coming off a really good season. What are we picking at 19 that is better than Carr? The only QB that could be left by then is Mac Jones.

I think that a second would do it.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by Number44

I think that a second would do it.

Maybe so and I’d do it today seeing as though Stafford is probably out

[GridIron26]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

That’s what it would take though. He’s been a very good QB for his career and coming off a really good season. What are we picking at 19 that is better than Carr? The only QB that could be left by then is Mac Jones.

That's a good point

[AnonEmouse]

I'd take Carr if he becomes available and the deal was good. Aside from 2017 he's steadily gotten better which suggests to me he's starting to peak. He's 29 which means he has years ahead of him. If you paired his 2020 season (best) with our D we'd definitely be better than 7-9. He'd need 2-3 more weapons, but if the trade wasn't too onerous we'd have picks left to get WR and TE, as well as fill OL and D gaps. And that's assuming we don't make good pickups in FA. In watching him on Hard Knocks and seeing him play, he reminds me of the same style of play as Favre, statistically he's arguably better at this stage of his career (rating, TD:INT).

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by AnonEmouse

I'd take Carr if he becomes available and the deal was good. Aside from 2017 he's steadily gotten better which suggests to me he's starting to peak. He's 29 which means he has years ahead of him. If you paired his 2020 season (best) with our D we'd definitely be better than 7-9. He'd need 2-3 more weapons, but if the trade wasn't too onerous we'd have picks left to get WR and TE, as well as fill OL and D gaps. And that's assuming we don't make good pickups in FA. In watching him on Hard Knocks and seeing him play, he reminds me of the same style of play as Favre, statistically he's arguably better at this stage of his career (rating, TD:INT).

I agree, his arm is good and he doesn’t make boneheaded decisions. I think the Raiders are dumb if they let him go

[MissouriSkin]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

I agree, his arm is good and he doesn’t make boneheaded decisions. I think the Raiders are dumb if they let him go

Might as well take a chance on him if Gruden does his perpetual “my QB isn’t good enough and I can’t really develop them like I’ve conned people into believing I can, so I’m looking for another one” schtick....for our 2nd or 3rd I’d do it today.

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

I agree, his arm is good and he doesn’t make boneheaded decisions. I think the Raiders are dumb if they let him go

Yes, he does bonehead decisions, trust me. If the Raiders want to get rid of him there is a reason.

[MissouriSkin]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Yes, he does bonehead decisions, trust me. If the Raiders want to get rid of him there is a reason.

Yes, Jon Gruden’s an idiot and a horrible coach.

[skinsfaninok]

Carr averages 10 INTs a season.. I’d say that’s not too bad

24 Passing TDs per as well.

He’s a solid Top 15 guy

[Pervis_Griffith]

Carr's price tag should be much less than Stafford.

Whoever we wind up with, it better not be too expensive.

Carr for a first rounder in any season, and I'll be pissed. But Carr for a 3rd rounder? I'd be happy as a clam.

It all depends on what it costs to get him.

[sdskinsfan2001]

I don't love Carr but we need a QB. A 1st seems a tad high but I wouldn't be too mad. A 2nd or lower and I'd be happy.

We need to add a stud WR2 for him though. He isn't an elite playmaker imo, he needs a strong cast (as most do).

[Chief X_Phackter]

Statistically, Carr and Stafford are basically the same guy, and Carr is younger. The compensation it would take to land them would likely be very comparable. Especially given the amount of teams that are looking at upgrading their QB situation.

[SkinzWin]

Originally Posted by Chief X_Phackter

Statistically, Carr and Stafford are basically the same guy, and Carr is younger. The compensation it would take to land them would likely be very comparable. Especially given the amount of teams that are looking at upgrading their QB situation.

But it’s supply and demand. You hear about 1/3 of the league inquiring about Stafford. You don’t hear that about Carr. To be honest, has anyone ever actually confirmed Carr is available, or is Carr all Twitter hopefuls hype?