A bad win is better than a good loss WFT vs Seattle post-game thread

[MTK]

The ball can move and even touch the ground, as long as you maintain control which it appeared that he did. He tucked his wrist under the ball as he hit the ground. Shouldn't have been overturned. I didn't see anything that was clear and obvious.

[calia]

Originally Posted by MTK

The ball can move and even touch the ground, as long as you maintain control which it appeared that he did. He tucked his wrist under the ball as he hit the ground. Shouldn't have been overturned. I didn't see anything that was clear and obvious.

This. That ending took a year off my life. I didn’t deserve it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[MTK]

Originally Posted by calia

This. That ending took a year off my life. I didn’t deserve it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

and just the fact the review took so long (unless there was some sort of unknown technical issue), if something was obvious it should be an easy and quick decision

[calia]

Originally Posted by MTK

and just the fact the review took so long (unless there was some sort of unknown technical issue), if something was obvious it should be an easy and quick decision

Exactly. If it takes 5 minutes to review, the evidence isn’t irrefutable. Bullshit call. And could have changed the outcome.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by MTK

The ball can move and even touch the ground, as long as you maintain control which it appeared that he did. He tucked his wrist under the ball as he hit the ground. Shouldn't have been overturned. I didn't see anything that was clear and obvious.

Exactly. His hand/wrist was completely under the ball and he never lost control. Having LT back is just huge. Hope you got a charity in mind. Giants, Eagles twice - that should be 8 wins. We need to get one from Dallas and or the Raiders to have a winning season. That Denver game is like a thorn in my side. That should have been the start of the streak.

[SunnySide]

Originally Posted by punch it in

Exactly. His hand/wrist was completely under the ball and he never lost control. Having LT back is just huge. Hope you got a charity in mind. Giants, Eagles twice - that should be 8 wins. We need to get one from Dallas and or the Raiders to have a winning season. That Denver game is like a thorn in my side. That should have been the start of the streak.

You couldnt tell with the angles they were showing while reviewing the call then right before they made the call overturning the tv feed showed a quick glimpse of an angle not seen before that appeared to show it hit the ground.

I think NY was studying that one angle we only got a glimpse of.

MNF tv camera angles were awesome. I love when theyd go sky camera behind the QB so you could see the routes developing.

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by SunnySide

You couldnt tell with the angles they were showing while reviewing the call then right before they made the call overturning the tv feed showed a quick glimpse of an angle not seen before that appeared to show it hit the ground.

I think NY was studying that one angle we only got a glimpse of.

MNF tv camera angles were awesome. I love when theyd go sky camera behind the QB so you could see the routes developing.

The ball can hit the ground though as long as his hand is under it and he doesn’t lose control. It was. He didn’t. That was a TD. Thank God this conversation is after a win. Lol.

[Chief X_Phackter]

Originally Posted by MTK

The ball can move and even touch the ground, as long as you maintain control which it appeared that he did. He tucked his wrist under the ball as he hit the ground. Shouldn't have been overturned. I didn't see anything that was clear and obvious.

Yep, that was BS. The longer that review took, the more I felt that they were searching for anything they could to overturn it, rather than objectively determine whether there was clear and obvious evidence that showed it was not a catch. Perhaps they had more angles than the broadcast showed, because from what they showed on the replays, there was not clear and obvious evidence in my opinion.