2022 Commanders off season thread part 1

[punch it in]

If they give up a first for him ill throw in the towel on this team. He is propped up by that defense, and run game. If he were our quarterback this past year we are no better and no worse. Id rather watch TH for a cheaper price and keep the first. I’ve waited this many years for a quarterback I can wait one more for a real one without panicking and throwing away picks and money for this guy.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by punch it in

If they give up a first for him ill throw in the towel on this team. He is propped up by that defense, and run game. If he were our quarterback this past year we are no better and no worse. Id rather watch TH for a cheaper price and keep the first. I’ve waited this many years for a quarterback I can wait one more for a real one without panicking and throwing away picks and money for this guy.

I think you're kidding yourself if you don't think Jimmy G would be a big upgrade over TH. I'm not even a big fan of JG, and I think this says more about how mediocre TH is, but JG would definitely make us instantly much more competitive. Would I give up a first rounder for him? Hell no.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by MTK

I think you're kidding yourself if you don't think Jimmy G would be a big upgrade over TH. I'm not even a big fan of JG, and I think this says more about how mediocre TH is, but JG would definitely make us instantly much more competitive. Would I give up a first rounder for him? Hell no.

The problem is the Alex Smith double whammy…the trade AND the contract. What are you gonna commit to both of these?

[MTK]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

The problem is the Alex Smith double whammy…the trade AND the contract. What are you gonna commit to both of these?

Yeah not much, I was just talking strictly about his abilities vs TH. I'm not a big fan of JG at all but he's definitely an upgrade. I'm definitely not interested in giving up significant assets and committing to him with a big extension.

The Carson Wentz situation is much more interesting to me.

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by MTK

I think you're kidding yourself if you don't think Jimmy G would be a big upgrade over TH. I'm not even a big fan of JG, and I think this says more about how mediocre TH is, but JG would definitely make us instantly much more competitive. Would I give up a first rounder for him? Hell no.

Upgrade? Yes. Big upgrade? Idk. Im just saying ill take TH, the cash, and the first over Jimmy and wait one more year to see what is available in the way of quarterbacks if those were my two options,….

[skinsfanthru&thru]

Originally Posted by punch it in

Upgrade? Yes. Big upgrade? Idk. Im just saying ill take TH, the cash, and the first over Jimmy and wait one more year to see what is available in the way of quarterbacks if those were my two options,….

Same, we aren’t saying TH4 isn’t better than Jimmy G, but Jimmy G ain’t worth the pick and cash only to maybe result in one or at most probably two more wins than TH4 and either a rookie gamble this year or holding off for next year.

But that doesn’t compare to the ridiculousness of the Chase Young to Detroit for Goff rumor. That’s hands down one of the dumbest trade rumors I’ve ever heard of before lol.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by punch it in

If they give up a first for him ill throw in the towel on this team. He is propped up by that defense, and run game. If he were our quarterback this past year we are no better and no worse. Id rather watch TH for a cheaper price and keep the first. I’ve waited this many years for a quarterback I can wait one more for a real one without panicking and throwing away picks and money for this guy.

He's in the tier of Cousins IMO, Give him a good line and Run game and he can win

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

He's in the tier of Cousins IMO, Give him a good line and Run game and he can win

I think KC is better. Jimmy has a very limited sample size, and it’s nothing special. He is gonna cash out undeservedly and should give half of it to his oline and rb’s back in SF. Lol

[KI Skins Fan]

Originally Posted by punch it in

I think KC is better. Jimmy has a very limited sample size, and it’s nothing special. He is gonna cash out undeservedly and should give half of it to his oline and rb’s back in SF. Lol

No truer words have ever been said.