Grade Rocky McIntosh

[D'BOYZ]

Originally Posted by TAFKAS

We got Brandon Lloyd for a 3rd round pick

hahaha forgot that trade hahaha but see that a good use of a draft pick you get a quality starter proven player for a pick that may or may not turn out to be great... .

the type of move that I don't get and that usually turns bad is the other you made trade future an current picks to draft higher for guy that may or may not turn out to be what you expect because at the end of the day you don't know.

is like the JP losman trade Bufallo tought he was worth the second, 1st and 5th they gave dallas because they where sure he was the QB of the future ( as you belive of Campbell) 2 years later they want to show him the door and it's benched?.

it usually cost you more than what you gained specially because of the charts because in case of trades a #2 this year is worth a #1 next year and we know that diference i ntalent between the first and second round.

[warriorzpath]

Originally Posted by D'BOYZ

hahaha forgot that trade hahaha but see that a good use of a draft pick you get a quality starter proven player for a pick that may or may not turn out to be great... .

the type of move that I don't get and that usually turns bad is the other you made trade future an current picks to draft higher for guy that may or may not turn out to be what you expect because at the end of the day you don't know.

is like the JP losman trade Bufallo tought he was worth the second, 1st and 5th they gave dallas because they where sure he was the QB of the future ( as you belive of Campbell) 2 years later they want to show him the door and it's benched?.

it usually cost you more than what you gained specially because of the charts because in case of trades a #2 this year is worth a #1 next year and we know that diference i ntalent between the first and second round.

Even if I were to agree (which I don't, because the Bills have a lot of other things wrong going on)- but how was this going to spell disaster for the redskins?

[724Skinsfan]

Your JP Losman example is way overstated. Your pinning your arguments on one example centered around a position (QB) that takes years to develop, if ever. JP Losman still has time to develop. He may be cut or traded and then play lights out offense or another team down the road. Plenty of QB's are drafted early and don't live up to expectations. I'm not sure what the attrition rate is for QB but I'm sure it is one of the lowest.
As far as acquiring a bunch of draft picks for a lower draft position. How about the Redskins getting the Saints draft picks for Ricky Williams. We got a ton of picks but we haven't won a championship as a result of those extra picks. We did make the playoffs this year special thanks to FA acquisitions like Moss, Brunell, Washington, Griffin, Daniels, Thomas, Rabach, Wynn.