KC Joyner picks skins...

[offiss]

I believe we are ready to win a SB but it all comes down to QB, and IMO that's a big question mark, even if Brunell steps up in the new offense can he stay healthy enough through the entire season? If not we have a problem Campbell I don't believe can win a SB at least not yet, which leaves us with a career backup in Collins who we really don't no how he will respond as a starter?

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by offiss

I believe we are ready to win a SB but it all comes down to QB, and IMO that's a big question mark, even if Brunell steps up in the new offense can he stay healthy enough through the entire season? If not we have a problem Campbell I don't believe can win a SB at least not yet, which leaves us with a career backup in Collins who we really don't no how he will respond as a starter?

Without Brunell, our offense becomes one dimensional. Wouldn't matter who played. That could keep this team from achieving great things. However there is no more reason for Redskin fans to worry about Brunell's health than any of the other 31 teams have to worry about their QBs health. Even with the recent broken finger, it's a non issue. Sure he might get injured and miss game time, but theres no reason to assume he will.

[wolfeskins]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Without Brunell, our offense becomes one dimensional. Wouldn't matter who played. That could keep this team from achieving great things. However there is no more reason for Redskin fans to worry about Brunell's health than any of the other 31 teams have to worry about their QBs health. Even with the recent broken finger, it's a non issue. Sure he might get injured and miss game time, but theres no reason to assume he will.

nice post but i would have to respectfully disagree with your one dimensional remark.

the skins have too many weapons on offense to become one dimensional. between moss, EL, Lloyd, cooley and portis defenses can't just stack the box to prevent the run. i think saunders would call just as many pass plays with campbell under center as he would with brunell, plus campbell would also be a threat to run as brunell was from time to time last year.

just my thoughts on the situation.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by wolfeskins

nice post but i would have to respectfully disagree with your one dimensional remark.

the skins have too many weapons on offense to become one dimensional. between moss, EL, Lloyd, cooley and portis defenses can't just stack the box to prevent the run. i think saunders would call just as many pass plays with campbell under center as he would with brunell, plus campbell would also be a threat to run as brunell was from time to time last year.

just my thoughts on the situation.

You are right to an extent. But the part I bolded, while is not necessarily something I disagree with, would be a problem. Brunell has impressively low INT totals, and Campbell would be a rookie. So if the playcalling didn't change, there would be a lot more game changing is. If the playcalling does change, you lose offensive efficency. It would create a bad situation

Just my two cents.

[mheisig]

Originally Posted by offiss

I believe we are ready to win a SB but it all comes down to QB, and IMO that's a big question mark, even if Brunell steps up in the new offense can he stay healthy enough through the entire season? If not we have a problem Campbell I don't believe can win a SB at least not yet, which leaves us with a career backup in Collins who we really don't no how he will respond as a starter?

I'd agree, but honestly it doesn't worry me about the QB situation. I'd love to win the SB this year, but I'm not counting on it.

If Brunell stays healthy and keeps up his production I'll be thrilled becuase we'll keep playing like we did last year.

If Brunell goes down and Campbell comes in, I'll still be thrilled. Sure it will probably be rough at first with a rookie at the helm, but overall I'll be excited to see the "QB of the future" step up and start playing.