Should the Redskins make a run at Brady Quinn?

[0421kidwell]

Why not?

[JWsleep]

???

[0421kidwell]

He's good!!! That's why

[SmootSmack]

Are you trying to set a record for most threads started?

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by 0421kidwell

Why not?

What would we trade for the first overall pick? Our first rounders in 2007, 2008, and 2009? And then what happens to Campbell, who projects very well as an NFL QB (even better than Quinn, who also projects well)?

That'd be a disaster. As long as he doesn't land in the division (i.e. Dallas), I'm happy.

[0421kidwell]

Yes I Am!! Is That A Problem

[SmootSmack]

Here's my opinion. No they shouldn't. 2007 start Campbell, let Brunell go (I believe they save money that way) and bring on a veteran who can play not named Collins. I don't know who's out there off hand but I don't think we benefit from having 2 QBs with no real NFL experience

[BMF21]

oh so now were bowing out......no 10 game run, from anyone, and we comeback and make the playoffs and win the superbowl,...... Matty where are you?...no MB peep talk, now were talking QB's.......wow, who would ever think

[Daseal]

Im not sold on Brady Quinn yet.

[hooskins]

[Rexi]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

What would we trade for the first overall pick? Our first rounders in 2007, 2008, and 2009? And then what happens to Campbell, who projects very well as an NFL QB (even better than Quinn, who also projects well)?

That'd be a disaster. As long as he doesn't land in the division (i.e. Dallas), I'm happy.

How does Campbell project better?

[ArtMonkDrillz]

I think the Raiders are going to hold on to the first overall pick (and therefore Quinn) like grim death, which is breathing down Al Davis' neck.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by Rexi

How does Campbell project better?

Theres an article written in the Pro Football Prospectus 2006 that has a good track record of projecting QBs based on their college stats, based on using Games Started and Completion %, and high numbers of both seem to correlate to success in the NFL. Campbell's projection is off the charts. Your boy, Alex Smith, fares pretty well by it too.

Quinns a 4 year starter for a major program in which his career completion % will hover around 60% at the end of the season. That's good for the system.

It has been wrong before. But in general, if you suck (a term used loosely, cause of the hype factor) in college, like Kyle Boller, who vastly outplayed his projection, you won't be much in the NFL.

[hooskins]

I assumed he is implying we lose out to try to get a top 5 pick, which I think is ridiculous.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by ArtMonkDrillz

I think the Raiders are going to hold on to the first overall pick (and therefore Quinn) like grim death, which is breathing down Al Davis' neck.

I also think that if the Raiders get the first pick, they will wait to use it on draft day until any chance of drafting a player who helps the franchise is gone.