HOF 2007 Preliminary Nominee List

[onlydarksets]

Buster, is there anyone you wouldn't let in?

Davis just didn't play well for long enough for the Hall. I know he had four great years, but he had three marginal years, too, even accounting for the injuries.

[irish]

Originally Posted by onlydarksets

Buster, is there anyone you wouldn't let in?

Davis just didn't play well for long enough for the Hall. I know he had four great years, but he had three marginal years, too, even accounting for the injuries.

I agree that TD didnt play well for long enough but he did play as good as long as Gayle Sayers did and GS is in.

As far as that list goes, Matthews is the only acceptable candidate.

[Monkeydad]

Originally Posted by irish

I agree that TD didnt play well for long enough but he did play as good as long as Gayle Sayers did and GS is in.

As far as that list goes, Matthews is the only acceptable candidate.

Sayers was a GREAT, GREAT RB...but if you compare stats, Davis kicks Sayers' butt.

Member - Pro Football Hall of Fame

Not taking away from Sayers...just showing Davis was a great RB in his short career.