Brady or Manning?

[hooskins]

Originally Posted by dall-assblows

by far brady. he is a winner plain and simple

Exactly. If you are talking fantasy, hands down Peyton. But Brady is a winner. That is all that matters.

EDIT: Manning tends to complain alot, which I find quite annoying. You tend not to hear much out of Brady.

Brady also takes paycuts to help the front office out, in keeping players. You almost NEVER hear of that in the NFL these days.

[offiss]

The only way to truly settle that debate is for the 2 to change teams, sometimes schemes have as much to do with a players success as talent itself, I alway's felt Marino would have at least 4 or 5 rings if he played for us in the 80's, Many QB's have had great success in the 9er's offense. I personally believe there is a lesser desparity between Brady and Manning as far as offense goes, both play in offenses that throw downfield, not a dink and dunk style O, Manning does have the benefit of playing in a dome most of the time, I also feel he has better talent around him, the equalizer is Brady has better coaching around him.

Bottom line it has to be Brady, I believe he's better than Montana. Peyton may get there but he has a long way to go to be considered as good as Brady.