Taylor is in the Pro Bowl!!!

[MTK]

So what's the argument against Samuels if we want to discuss nobody on this team deserving a Pro Bowl nod??

How about Cooley, I think we could argue that he "deserved" a nod more than Witten.

[Sheriff Gonna Getcha]

Originally Posted by Mattyk72

So what's the argument against Samuels if we want to discuss nobody on this team deserving a Pro Bowl nod??

How about Cooley, I think we could argue that he "deserved" a nod more than Witten.

Cooley and Samuels definately "deserved" to go for two reasons: (1) objectively, they had damn good season; and (2) they had better seasons than almost all others at their respective positions.

[celts32]

Originally Posted by Mattyk72

So what's the argument against Samuels if we want to discuss nobody on this team deserving a Pro Bowl nod??

How about Cooley, I think we could argue that he "deserved" a nod more than Witten.

I don't feel like the line in general started playing well and aserting itself until the season was already lost. Same with Cooley, his play picked up in the second half of the season when they were already out of it. I agree that those are the only two with any argument at all. You can make a case for those two if you try to...My point on ST though is that he literally had an awful season...not good or even average but awful. His only good game was Carolina IMO.

[Pocket$ $traight]

Originally Posted by celts32

I don't feel like the line in general started playing well and aserting itself until the season was already lost. Same with Cooley, his play picked up in the second half of the season when they were already out of it. I agree that those are the only two with any argument at all. You can make a case for those two if you try to...My point on ST though is that he literally had an awful season...not good or even average but awful. His only good game was Carolina IMO.

Taylor's season was no worse than Roy Williams. Roy Williams is not a safety, he is an out of position linebacker.

New Orleans humiliated Roy specifically as well as the rest of the Cowboys defense. They didn't do that to the Tarantula. In Cowboys losses, Roy was a joke. Why don't I hear just as much criticism about his selection?

[celts32]

Originally Posted by Grim21Reaper

Taylor's season was no worse than Roy Williams. Roy Williams is not a safety, he is an out of position linebacker.

New Orleans humiliated Roy specifically as well as the rest of the Cowboys defense. They didn't do that to the Tarantula. In Cowboys losses, Roy was a joke. Why don't I hear just as much criticism about his selection?

Roy Williams had a bad season as well...which bad season was better is not a debate I am up for...Taylor did not play well at all this season. We all know that...what Roy Williams does with the cowfcks is irrelevent to me. I am concerned with ST's poor play and I don't want his head getting big this offseason thinking that he had a pro bowl season...that's my only point.