Be Bold 4/15/07

[MTK]

Originally Posted by Redskin Rich

I am not sold on JC.... I don't think we have had a QB we could be confident in since Brad Johnson. I also want a 6'4" speed demon WR that will scare DB's in the league. In other words, someone built like Westbrook only with the heart to go along with the talent.

So would you want them to pick up another QB or are you willing to see what JC can do?

[Redskin Rich]

Originally Posted by Mattyk72

So would you want them to pick up another QB or are you willing to see what JC can do?

The simple answer is yes.... They should definately send Brunnell to the old folks home at this point and pick up an experienced QB that still has some life in him. While I am not sold on JC, we did trade to get the extra first round pick for him. He did not show last season that he is an unquestionable starter.... let us have a competetion for the job and see what shakes out.

I would rather see us use our pick for a stud WR. Right now we have quality guys... comperable to a Gary Clark (who should be a HOFer).... but without Art Monk, Clark would not have had the success he had.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by Redskin Rich

The simple answer is yes.... They should definately send Brunnell to the old folks home at this point and pick up an experienced QB that still has some life in him. While I am not sold on JC, we did trade to get the extra first round pick for him. He did not show last season that he is an unquestionable starter.... let us have a competetion for the job and see what shakes out.

What QB is out there that is worth bringing in at this point??

[724Skinsfan]

Originally Posted by Mattyk72

What QB is out there that is worth bringing in at this point??

Eggs-freakin-zackly! That's an easy one = no one.
I take that back. I would consider Trent Green as a backup to JC in place of Mark Brunell.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by 724Skinsfan

Eggs-freakin-zackly! That's an easy one = no one.
I take that back. I would consider Trent Green as a backup to JC in place of Mark Brunell.

But is he worth trading for?

[724Skinsfan]

Originally Posted by Mattyk72

But is he worth trading for?

Right now, I would say Brunell for Green, straight up. It would be a slight upgrade at best. In other words, it's not really all that worth it.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by 724Skinsfan

Right now, I would say Brunell for Green, straight up. It would be a slight upgrade at best. In other words, it's not really all that worth it.

Why would T. Green come here? He wants to start. And even if it's an upgrade it's a real small one. We are going to have to go with who we have. Brunell and Collins as back-ups. We should be Ok. Brunell is fine to play 1-3 games if needed.

[Redskin Rich]

Originally Posted by Mattyk72

What QB is out there that is worth bringing in at this point??

724 just took my dream answer... Trent Green is available and has proven he can get the job done.

I know he could never come back to DC, at this point in their respective careers, Gus would hold up better than Brunell. There are several more experienced QB's out there that can be better than where we are.

( and yes, I am well aware of the fact that since I mentioned Gus in a positive light, the attacks will be fast and relentless now)

[MTK]

Originally Posted by Redskin Rich

724 just took my dream answer... Trent Green is available and has proven he can get the job done.

I know he could never come back to DC, at this point in their respective careers, Gus would hold up better than Brunell. There are several more experienced QB's out there that can be better than where we are.

( and yes, I am well aware of the fact that since I mentioned Gus in a positive light, the attacks will be fast and relentless now)

I'm not sure of the benefit of bringing in an aging QB who's best days are behind him to replace, well, an aging QB who's best days are behind him.

Gus?

I guess I'll have to ask again... what QB is out there that is worth bringing in at this point??

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by Redskin Rich

The simple answer is yes.... They should definately send Brunnell to the old folks home at this point and pick up an experienced QB that still has some life in him. While I am not sold on JC, we did trade to get the extra first round pick for him. He did not show last season that he is an unquestionable starter.... let us have a competetion for the job and see what shakes out.

I would rather see us use our pick for a stud WR. Right now we have quality guys... comperable to a Gary Clark (who should be a HOFer).... but without Art Monk, Clark would not have had the success he had.

So what did you expect from a qb who was in his first year starting? Remember the guy got no reps w/ the first team since he was drafted. Who do you want to bring in to compete w/ JC? Who is out on the waiver wire that is better? Do u suggest we trade draft picks for 65 year old Trent Green?