Is Kurt Warner back?

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by jsarno

Ummm no. I'm not a fan. He is a terrible QB. Great scrambler...he's up there with Vick as one of the best ever, but in the pocket, he is terrible, one of the worst in the league.

Why is it ridiculous? If you have no qb to throw you the ball, you won't have good numbers as a WR. He throws the ball all over the place.

If a team decided to take the MLB and shadow Young to neutralize him, they would win. Tennessee HAS to have Young scramble all day long or they will lose cause his arm will not win them games.

Don't you think "terrible" is a bit extreme? I think he's shown real improvement over the past several games and is becoming a more complete QB overall.

I'd probably say the Titans are my 2nd favorite team, and I remember really wanting them to draft Leinart but the more I watch Young the more pleased I am with the selection.

[jsarno]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

Don't you think "terrible" is a bit extreme? I think he's shown real improvement over the past several games and is becoming a more complete QB overall.

I'd probably say the Titans are my 2nd favorite team, and I remember really wanting them to draft Leinart but the more I watch Young the more pleased I am with the selection.

I will say this, he looked a lot better last week vs the Saints, but who can't get back on track vs the Saints. Every once in a while Vick would do well throwing the ball too. I'd like to see him play a good defense and do well. He played Jacksonville and only passed for 78 yards...78 yards!
Even in the Saints game the WR's had to make a lot of adjustments to catch his throws, but he was more on the money than he had been.
After the bye they have Atlanta...this year's doormat. So I am not expecting him to fail miserably there. But the two games after that are at Tampa, and at Houston, and I feel the titan will lose both those games, and it will be because Young won't be able to beat them with his arm.