Vince Young overrated?

[GMScud]

Originally Posted by Mattyk72

By the way I should cite where I'm getting these numbers from

Vince Young: Situational Stats

Jason Campbell: Situational Stats

A couple of things that bother me when looking at Campbell's stats:

-His second half rating is only 71.3, compared to 88.8 in the first half
-Also, in close games (margin of 0-7pts), his rating is only 68.6.
-In the 4th quarter he's only got a 68.3 rating
-In the 4th quarter with a lead of 7 or less it's only 59.9

Now granted we've only played 5 games and this isn't really an accurate measuring stick yet, but I don't like those numbers.

As far as VY is concerned, I think his rookie of the year award was deserving, and he led the Titans to a great second half last year. He's a winner and a leader, and I'm definitely not read to call him overrated.