Cowboys or Giants: Who do you want to win?

[Chief X_Phackter]

Originally Posted by Southpaw

First of all, no one is handing Dallas the division. They are effing taking it. And I love the idea that "all we have to do is beat Dallas twice"... There's an easy task. What about this Redskins team tells you they can take two from the best team in the NFC?

Those of us that think that Dallas should win are just being realistic, and realistically, Washington's best chance at the playoffs is a wild card. Dallas beating the Giants and Washington beating Philly will be the best scenario. Then Washington only has to outplay the Giants in the second half of the season, rather than the Giants AND Cowboys.

Great, Dallas is taking the Division. Let's pack up and go home now. I mean if we can't beat Dallas, what makes you think we can beat the Giants in New York?

How about a little optimism as opposed to what you call "realism", because realistically, anybody can beat anybody in this league. All the redskins offense needs to do is start averaging about 7-10 more points a game and there aren't many teams out there that can beat them.

[Southpaw]

Originally Posted by Chief X_Phackter

Great, Dallas is taking the Division. Let's pack up and go home now. I mean if we can't beat Dallas, what makes you think we can beat the Giants in New York?

How about a little optimism as opposed to what you call "realism", because realistically, anybody can beat anybody in this league. All the redskins offense needs to do is start averaging about 7-10 more points a game and there aren't many teams out there that can beat them.

That's a bit more than optimism... That's a flat out fairy tale. Washington hasn't been able to do that since Gibbs returned. And I think I'm being optimistic by saying they'll make the playoffs. This team is by no means dominant, and they are going to have to win a lot of tough games just to grab the wild card.

[Chief X_Phackter]

Originally Posted by Southpaw

That's a bit more than optimism... That's a flat out fairy tale. Washington hasn't been able to do that since Gibbs returned. And I think I'm being optimistic by saying they'll make the playoffs. This team is by no means dominant, and they are going to have to win a lot of tough games just to grab the wild card.

Well, at some point with the weapons they have on offense things have to start to click. I believe JC will start to hit those deep balls he's been just missing, he'll gain confidence and they will get rolling. If you want to call it a fairy tale, that's your deal. I don't think it's much of a stretch. I agree that they will have to win a lot of games just to get the wild card, but in the end, I don't think there is going to be much separating the division winner from the wild card(s) in the NFC East.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by Chief X_Phackter

Great, Dallas is taking the Division. Let's pack up and go home now. I mean if we can't beat Dallas, what makes you think we can beat the Giants in New York?

How about a little optimism as opposed to what you call "realism", because realistically, anybody can beat anybody in this league. All the redskins offense needs to do is start averaging about 7-10 more points a game and there aren't many teams out there that can beat them.

I'm with you on this. I don't think we're that far off. Really, it's just a matter of turning these drives that end in field goals into drives that end in touchdowns. Not an easy task but it can be done. The challenge is really to get the passing game going, which I think won't fully happen until they get McCardell (who at this time I think may be their best receiver) more involved.

This weekend is huge for us, but it's too early to hand the division to the Cowboys. Look at the Giants last year. They were 6-2 at this point and then barely made the playoffs at 8-8. Not likely the Cowboys will collapse like that, but as long as we take care of our business I think we can stay in the thick of things.

But then, I guess that's why I'm not part of the Tylenol laced with cyanide crowd around here.

[Southpaw]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

But then, I guess that's why I'm not part of the Tylenol laced with cyanide crowd around here.

The thing is, even the people(at least within this thread) that think that Cowboys will win the division still think Washington has a good shot at the playoffs. There aren't any offiss type replies here. And all I'm saying is it will be a lot easier to outplay the Giants down the stretch than both the Giants and Cowboys. Of course the goal is to win every game, but that's not likely to happen.