Five That Have Been Quiet

[GMScud]

Originally Posted by 12thMan

...but these are the top 5 names that jumped out to me that haven't had their usual dominant season....

I wouldn't say Rivers has "usual dominant seasons." He was good last year but not great, and IMO didn't deserve the Pro-Bowl nod he received. I think a lot of people expected a very good year from him given Norv's track record with QBs, but after only one good season ever I don't think he deserves to be on this list. I totally agree with the other four names though.

Instead of Rivers, how about McNabb? Maybe even Carson Palmer with an 88 rating and 14 INTS? Or last year's MVP candidate Drew Brees with 15tds-14INTS and a 83 rating? Possibly Steve Smith (I know, that offense in Carolina is miserable)?