What about Tiki?

[Giantone]

Portis........


Stat page..................

Clinton Portis

[Redskins8588]

Originally Posted by Giantone

The HOF has nothing to do with SuperBowls,ask Dan Marino.

That quote right there is where you compared Tiki to Marino. By stating this you are saying that Tiki has stats just as good as Marino, therefor Tiki does not need to win a super bowl to get in the HOF.

You are correct that this year FAVRE and not

Originally Posted by Giantone

Farve

did pass Marino. Favre does have a superbow win so even if he didn't surpass Marino statistically he still would be a HOF'er.

Again, you are correct that you never mentioned Emmit Smith, but since Tiki was a running back I felt that he should be compared to a running back that has the stats that Tiki can only dream about. Hell, Tiki can only dream about seeing the endzone as many times as Portis did.

Originally Posted by Giantone

no matter how far behind Emmit he is ............portis is twice that.

Ok, are you in remedial math by chance? If so I will try to make this simple for you.

Emmit Smith - 18,355 yards
Tiki Barber - 10,449 yards
Clinton Portis - 7,715 yards

So if you do the math correctly Portis is not twice what Tiki is behind Emmit. Now I will admit that I do not think in any way that Portis will catch up to Emmit, but I KNOW FOR A FACT Portis will surpass Tiki!!! Remember Portis only needs 2,734 more yards just to tie with Tiki, which can be done like Matty said in 2 years for him...

Oh, and I am still waiting for your support as to why Tiki is a HOF running back? Thanks for listing CP's stat page, but I already know how good he is...