What if...?

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by SUNRA

You know I can respect those of you who have so much confidence for Ramsey but I have made it clear from last year that Ramsey to me is the embodiment of so many QB's in the past who have shown flashes of greatness but who never reach their full potential due to a lack of instinctive knowledge to make the big plays when it is absolutely neccessary like Rothelisberger has shown. I believe based on what I have seen from Rothlisberger since preseason that he is the kind of QB of the future for any team. 6'5 , 245lbs. is no small deal and mobile with the instincts to get out of the pocket and complete his pass is what Redskins fans have wanted since Brad Johnson. If it were my choice, I would have to go with Big Ben over Taylor because it's much harder to find a QB with this kind of size and insightfulness that he exhibits.

I hear what you're saying SUNRA. Right now Ben Roth is looking phenomenal but a lot of that is because he's been put in a position to play. I think ultimately we'll see the top QBs who were drafted last April playing-Roethlisberger, Manning, Rivers-and see that, while I think Big Ben may be slightly better than the others the difference isn't that great.

For Safety though, it was Sean Taylor and everyone else. Taylor was clearly the best safety in the draft and you could make an argument that he was the best defensive player period.